Upon its release,
Wide Open Spaces received favorable reviews from critics. Music critic
Robert Christgau gave the album a two-star honorable mention, simply stating that the "blonds have more brains (than they get credit for)."
Los Angeles Times wrote that "this tradition-rooted
Texas trio knows its way around
country,
western,
honky-tonk,
bluegrass,
folk and
country-rock." Concluding the review, it deemed that the "range, plus their sweet, assured three-part harmonies, Natalie Maines' attractively steely lead vocals, and savvy song selection have propelled this major-label debut into the Top 10." In a retrospective review by
Stephen Thomas Erlewine of
AllMusic, he stated that it hit a "sweet spot" and described the album as "appealing to many different audiences" and "eclectic without being elitist." He described Natalie Maines' voice as "powerful" and "bluesy" to "give these songs a compelling center" and "versatile" to "[negotiate] the twists and turns of these songs without a hitch, easily moving from the vulnerability of "
You Were Mine" to the snarl of "Give It Up or Let Me Go." Concluding his review, he praised the "remarkably wide range" as "effortlessly eclectic" and the group for "bringing [the album] all together with their attitude and understated musicality." ==Track listing==