"The Scholar Gipsy" was written in 1853, probably immediately after "
Sohrab and Rustum". In an 1857 letter to his brother
Tom, referring to their friendship with Theodore Walrond and the poet
Arthur Hugh Clough, Arnold wrote that "The Scholar Gipsy" was "meant to fix the remembrance of those delightful wanderings of ours in the
Cumner hills before they were quite effaced". Arnold revisited these scenes many years later in his elegy for Arthur Hugh Clough, "
Thyrsis", a companion-piece and, some would say, a sequel to "The Scholar Gipsy". "The Scholar Gipsy", like "Requiescat" and "
Sohrab and Rustum", first appeared in Arnold's
Poems (1853), published by
Longmans. During the 20th century it was many times published as a booklet, either by itself or with "Thyrsis". It appears in
The Oxford Book of English Verse and in some editions of
Palgrave's
Golden Treasury despite its being, at 250 lines, considerably longer than most of the poems in either anthology. == Critical opinions ==