Given his accomplishments as a high-school basketball player, Gilmore was heavily recruited by college basketball programs across the country. While his family had hoped that Gilmore would attend the nearby
University of Connecticut and play his college basketball there, he opted for the
University of Colorado. During the 1950s, the University of Colorado belonged to the
Big Eight Conference, which, with players like
Wilt Chamberlain and
Bill Bridges at Kansas, was the strongest NCAA conference during those years. In his first year playing for the University of Colorado varsity team, 1959-60, Wilky Gilmore, who stood 6'6", started at forward. He led Colorado in both scoring and rebounding, and was named to the All-Big Eight first team. Colorado finished the year with a 14-10 record. Over the 1960-61 season, despite suffering a mid-season knee injury that would reduce his mobility throughout the remainder of his playing career, Gilmore continued to excel, averaging 17.2 points and 8.3 rebounds per game. Colorado finished with a 15-10 record, and Gilmore was named to the second-team all-star squad for the NCAA's District Five. During his three seasons with the varsity team at the University of Colorado, Wilky Gilmore played for
Coach Russell "Sox" Walseth, who coached the Buffaloes from 1956 – 1976. Over his 20-year tenure, Walseth became the winningest coach in the history of University of Colorado men's basketball, and remains one of the few coaches to have led both the men's and the women's teams at the same NCAA institution. During the 1950s and early-1960s, the NCAA did not systematically track assists, which in modern-day basketball are considered a key statistics and measure of contributions to one's team. However, it is reported that Gilmore was a skillful and selfless passer, who placed his team above his own scoring totals. As coach Walseth put it, "He's invaluable to us whether or not he scores a single point. His team spirit is terrific. He wants us to have a good team, not just for himself to have a good season." At the time of his graduation in 1962, with 1,026 total points scored over three seasons, Wilky Gilmore was the second-highest scorer in
Colorado Buffaloes team history. Despite his many accomplishments in his three years of varsity basketball with the Buffaloes, Gilmore's play was definitely affected in his last season and a half by the nagging effects of his knee injury: As a
Sports Illustrated in December 1961 article put it, "Much of Colorado's substantial hope rests on the slow-healing knee of fast Wilky Gilmore, the team's best shot." ==
NCAA 1961 men's basketball scandal ==