Early career, 1987–1991 The England rugby team were in a period of transition following failure at the
1987 Rugby World Cup. There was a new manager,
Geoff Cooke, and a new coach,
Roger Uttley, replacing
Mike Weston and
Martin Green. England's recent record was one of considerable underachievement, described by one writer as a "sprawling desert of failure, stretching back as far as 1963" — they had only won a single
Five Nations Championship since then,
in 1980. The new season offered good prospects for younger players, as league rugby was introduced for the first time, establishing a "proper system which rewarded progress";
Divisional Championships, which brought the best club players into regional teams, would not necessarily be the main method of selection in future. In February 1987 Carling made his debut for
Harlequins against the Metropolitan Police. He soon played for England B in a 22–9 win over France B. Carling sensed he had a chance of earning his first senior England cap when
Kevin Simms, a former England Schoolboys teammate, was selected to play against
Romania. As Carling knew the strengths and weaknesses of Simms and "wasn't in awe of him", expectation that he might match this achievement grew. Around Christmas 1987, Carling took part in an England trial for the
upcoming Five Nations Championship. Though still expected to pursue a military career, Carling abandoned these plans. As rugby was an amateur game at this point, he accepted an executive post with
Mobil Oil to make ends meet.
1991–1995 Under Carling England started to challenge and beat the established rugby union powers such as
New Zealand and Australia, and their success helped to make rugby union a more popular sport in England. English victories over New Zealand and South Africa in 1993 were perhaps the peak of England's performance under Carling. Carling's career included the 1993
British Lions tour to New Zealand. He underachieved on that tour, a pattern attributed by coach
Ian McGeechan and manager
Geoff Cooke as at least partly due to his failing to secure the captaincy (this instead going to
Gavin Hastings of Scotland) but also due to the ascendency in the centre of both
Jeremy Guscott and
Scott Gibbs of Wales. McGeechan and Cooke disclosed that Carling came close to voluntarily withdrawing from the squad; he did regain his test place and played a notable role in the third test. McGeechan commented in his autobiography that Carling's failure to rise to the occasion as a Lion (in contrast to Guscott) may be seen by some as the difference between his legacy as a good player and a great player. Also in 1993, he became the second captain after
John Pullin to lead and beat all of the “Big Three” Southern Hemisphere sides: , and , after beating the All Blacks 15–9. He had earlier led England to wins against Australia in November 1988, and South Africa in November 1992. As captain, he had 2 wins against Australia, 1 against New Zealand, and 2 against South Africa.
1995 World Cup In the run-up to the 1995 World Cup, after England returned to form with their third Grand Slam in five years, Carling described the
Rugby Football Union general committee as "57 old farts" which led to his sacking as captain. The incident had been provoked by administrator Dudley Wood's comments about England players' alleged desire to cheat by breaking the amateur ethic. He was quickly reinstated due to public pressure and following a public apology was able to go to the
1995 Rugby World Cup. After a slow start, England found form and subsequently won all their group games, then knocked out Australia in the quarter-final 25–22, thanks to a last-minute drop-goal from
Rob Andrew. They were well beaten by New Zealand in the semi-final, largely thanks to four tries from
Jonah Lomu. Although Carling himself scored two tries towards the end of that game, and set up two more for
Rory Underwood, England lost 45–29. The subsequent loss in the third place play-off, against France, was England's first loss to the French in seven years. Following his resignation from the England captaincy, he continued to be selected as an outside centre, usually with Guscott or
Phil de Glanville; the latter succeeded him as captain. ==Life after rugby==