As president of the young men's Democratic club of Columbus, Chipley had made himself obnoxious to the carpetbaggers and scalawags, black and white, in that city and to that fact was charged in the murder of George W. Ashburn by what was later described as the "Columbus Ku Klux Klan". Ashburn, a
Radical Republican member of the Georgia government, was murdered on March 31, 1868, following warnings by outspoken Democrats to cease his outspoken support for
Reconstruction. In the resultant investigation into his murder, Chipley and others were identified by witness Amanda Patterson, who had been the prostitute with Ashburn, as one of several men who broke into the house Ashburn was visiting; Patterson also told investigators that Chipley had, prior to the murder, told her "We are going to kill old Ashburn the night of the day he speaks [at a political meeting]." Previously, she had testified she did not know Chipley or any other of the men whom she had said she had known. With former
Confederate Vice President Alexander H. Stephens representing the defense, Chipley and his alleged co-conspirators were tried before a military court (a civil court not being used as a result of Georgia's temporary military governorship). The prosecution, aided by federal investigator
Hiram C. Whitley, assembled evidence of guilt to the point that sympathetic Southern newspapers switched from outright denial of Klan guilt to diminishing the status of the crime; as the
Macon Weekly Telegraph hypothesized, perhaps the defendants had intended only to
tar and feather Ashburn but when he resisted, the Klan members shot him in "quasi self-defense." Northern newspapers reported the defense as resorting to tedious details in their attempt to clear the accused, with the
Chicago Tribune recording the military judges as "growing somewhat weary of the great mass of trifling and irrelevant matter introduced by the defense." More reliable testimony—mainly from Charles Marshall, who admitted to being next to several named men (not Chipley) who murdered Ashburn, resulted in the exoneration of Chipley and other Columbus defendants. Stephens' connections with Democratic members of the Georgia House of Representatives lead to Democrats voting to ratify the
Fourteenth Amendment, a Republican goal, which in turn caused the re-admittance of Georgia to the Union and the invalidation of the military court proceedings. As a result, Chipley and the others charged in Ashburn's death were released. ==Railroad executive==