In 1844, Havemeyer entered local politics with the
Democratic Party as an
elector for
James K. Polk and
George M. Dallas during the
United States presidential election. He had been a supporter of President
Andrew Jackson. He was also friendly with President
Martin Van Buren with whom he had corresponded and urged vehemently to emulate Jackson's firmness in the face of popular outcry. In 1844, the Democrats of the ward Havemeyer lived in were divided into two factions about equal in strength. To avoid a conflict, it was determined to send to the
Tammany Hall convention three influential men, irrespective of factional feeling. James T. Brady, Gustavus A. Conover, and Havemeyer were selected. Then at the state convention of the Democratic Party, held at
Syracuse September 4, 1844, Havemeyer was nominated for the office of presidential elector. Havemeyer attempted to reform the powers of the
Common Council, leading to the drafting of a new government charter that provided for direct election of department heads who had previously been appointed by the council. In 1846, together with
Robert B. Minturn and
Gulian C. Verplanck, Havemeyer strove to abolish the abuses practised on immigrants. The result of their efforts was the Board of Emigration Commissioners, of which Havemeyer was the first president.
Return to politics In 1859, he was nominated by
Tammany Hall to run against Democratic candidate
Fernando Wood, who had lost favor with some of the Tammany factions, and the Republican candidate
George Opdyke. Havemeyer narrowly lost to Wood 30,000 to 27,000, with Opdyke receiving 23,000 votes. During the
American Civil War, Havemeyer was a strong advocate of the Union and urged the
abolition of slavery as a war measure. During his third term, in the reorganization of the city government political organization under the Charter of 1873, several of his nominations were opposed by the Board of Aldermen. The greater part of his time was spent in wrangles with the aldermen and other city officers. Several of his appointments were controversial, for example, he reappointed two police commissioners who had been convicted of violating their oaths of office. An application was made to the
Governor of New York for his removal from office, a step which the executive declined to take. ==Personal life==