On August 14, 1832, McSherry was elected the first procurator of the Jesuit
mission in the United States; soon thereafter, Kenney requested that the
Jesuit Superior General elevate the mission to the status of a province. This request was granted on August 28, and McSherry set sail for Rome from New York City so he could receive instructions on how to establish the new province. The territory of the new province was defined according to the borders of the state of Maryland, and the province was officially established on February 2, 1833. On February 7, 1833, McSherry was made the first provincial superior of the Maryland Province of the Society of Jesus. but was soon confronted with a considerable debt that Georgetown College had accrued, as well as disciplinary issues within the institution. As provincial, McSherry advocated for the relocation of the Jesuit
novitiate from Georgetown to
Frederick, Maryland because this would reduce expenses, which were of great concern because the novitiate was in significant debt as well; although this relocation was not complete until after his term ended, the first efforts at relocation were made during this time, so that St. Stanislaus Novitiate had a presence in Frederick by 1833. By the end of his tenure, the province's schools were under strain due to a lack of Jesuits to staff them. Despite this, the province operated several missions throughout rural Maryland, Virginia, and
Pennsylvania, whose successes were largely attributed to McSherry. In order to support them, McSherry unsuccessfully sought to obtain the Superior General's approval to sell some of the Jesuits' land and farms in 1835, which totaled across Maryland by 1837. The Second Provincial Council of Baltimore in 1833 entrusted to the province a new mission to the
freed blacks who had
returned to Liberia. However, the already-shorthanded province was unable to perform the task. The province's financial difficulties were further compounded by the fact that the farms, worked by slaves, had become unprofitable. As a result, McSherry and Mulledy together impressed upon the provincial congregation of 1835 the need to sell the province's slaves.
Slave sale In 1836, McSherry and the province's leadership were seriously considering selling all the nearly-300 slaves who remained under the ownership of the Maryland Province. A formal assessment of the moral and economic advantages and disadvantages of the proposed sale was drawn up by
Stephen Larigaudelle Dubuisson. The financial concerns become acute due to the increasing unprofitability of the farms and the growing debt accrued by Georgetown's recent construction projects. After the leadership returned a vote of six to four in favor of sale, the Superior General Jan Roothaan approved the transaction on October 27, 1836, on the condition that the purchasers guarantee the right of the slaves to practice their Catholic faith, that their families not be separated, and that those who were old or ill be allowed to remain with the Jesuits and be cared for. During this period, McSherry began to experience symptoms that later proved to be
stomach cancer, and was occasionally unable to discharge his office. Following his requests to be relieved of the office, Roothaan permitted his resignation in October 1837. Thomas Mulledy replaced McSherry as provincial superior, and McSherry assumed Mulledy's role as the
president of Georgetown. In addition to McSherry's petitions, this swap was motivated by Roothaan's dissatisfaction with McSherry's failure to keep him apprised of the province's affairs—which was largely due to his worsening illness—and his lack of confidence in Mulledy's administrative abilities. Due to the
panic of 1837, the sale was not executed until the following year. and much outrage within the Jesuit order over the morality of the sale ensued; this outrage was reflected also by Roothaan, whose orders on which the sale was conditioned were not followed. == Georgetown College ==