On 2 January, 1869, James was appointed a
Vice-Chancellor of the
Court of Chancery, receiving the customary knighthood. The next year, 1870, he was appointed a
Lord Justice of Appeal of the
Court of Appeal in Chancery. He was also sworn to the
Privy Council. He had a reputation as an eminent and shrewd judge, learned in the law, with a talent for concise but clear enunciation of principles. While on the Court of Appeal in Chancery, he decided several cases under the Companies Acts and the
Bankruptcy Act 1869 (
32 & 33 Vict. c. 71). In 1874, James gave the decision of the
Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in a significant constitutional case from Canada,
Maher v Town Council of Portland. The case concerned the interpretation of section 93 of the British North America Act 1867 (now the
Constitution Act, 1867), dealing with publicly funded religious
separate schools, and has been cited by the Canadian courts in subsequent cases dealing with separate schools. ==Interest in India==