Watson kept records for Strang and accompanied Strang until Strang was murdered on Beaver Island on June 18, 1856. This led to fear that other Strangite leaders would be killed, so they left the island. Watson left for
Chicago, Illinois, in July of that year, and the Strangite colony disintegrated. Watson then moved to
Livingston, Wisconsin. After some time, however, he was approached by Lorenzo Dow Hickey, who was one of the Strangite church's
apostles. Hickey convinced Watson to move to
Black River Falls, Wisconsin, where several of the residents of Beaver Island were living. Six years later, Hickey convinced Watson to move again, but this time to
Boyne City, Michigan. There Watson became a leader of the Strangites. He published pamphlets and preached to the people. He wrote letters from 1862 to 1883 to affirm Strang's authority. Watson lived in
Michigan until 1891. ==Contributions to the Strangite faith==