Steve Baltin from
Cash Box named "Wonderwall" Pick of the Week, describing the song as "a perfect example of melodic pop." He added, "Following the more uptempo riff of '
Morning Glory', this single will remind listeners of the anthemic single '
Live Forever', a track that generated massive airplay on multiple formats last year. Look for the same results for this lovely near
ballad. A simple, sweet song, it shows why Oasis is rapidly becoming one of music's great singles bands." Kevin Courtney from
Irish Times declared it as a "genuine Oasis gem", "with its aching string arrangements and evocative vocals". Michael Bonner from
Melody Maker named it Single of the Week, praising it as "a mesmeric declaration of love — haunting, beautiful and effortlessly simple — and, unless you've been locked in a coal cellar for the last two months, you should know it forwards, backwards and sideways by now." Another
Melody Maker editor,
David Stubbs, said, "'Wonderwall', with its explicit
George Harrison reference, doesn't bother to conceal another nod at
The Beatles, but the real problem here is that
Liam doesn't seem capable of modulating his voice to suit the pensively orchestrated backdrop — a bit of a subtlety deficiency." Pan-European magazine
Music & Media wrote, "A swirling rock song that slowly builds to epic proportions. Nicely chiming acoustic guitars and psyched-up strings support Liam Gallagher's trademark declamatory and plaintive vocals. Not the easiest song for
EHR, but a sure grower." John Robinson from
NME commented, "'Wonderwall' instead turns out to be the best example of Liam's indispensability to
Noel as we are plunged into the depths of a doomed urban romance. Fires have gone out, wills to live have departed, yet we still witness Liam questioning whether
Maybe you could be the one to save me. And yet the entirely twisted delivery turns it from a slightly sappy idea into a fantastically bleak song, adding an all-consuming anger to the sense of desperation." In a separate review, Robinson felt it "is one of Oasis' best records because it manages to be immensely robust while still being one of Noel's most lyrically personal songs".
Andrew Harrison from
Select wrote, "'Wonderwall' is a near acoustic song that wears many signs of its maturity, but heavily. There is a (good) attempt to resonate personal failure with the redemptive power of The Beatles ("
Backbeat, the word is on the street/That the fire in your eyes is out"). Liam goes flat once too often on the chorus." Leesa Daniels from
Smash Hits gave it a top score of five out of five and named it "Oasis' version of a love song." She added, "Absolutely beautiful." Another
Smash Hits editor,
Mark Frith, praised it as a highlight of the album, "mid-paced, brilliantly sung by Liam and, if it wasn't for
Queen ['
Heaven for Everyone'], a No. 1 hit!" ==Cover art==