Hua Hsu praised the 38-CD
50th Anniversary Archive album's attention to historical detail in
The New Yorker, saying "
Woodstock – Back to the Garden was produced by Andy Zax and Steve Woolard. Zax, an accomplished archivist and reissue specialist, spent more than a decade putting it together from hundreds of tapes that had never been consolidated in one place. In the process of reconstructing the festival, hour by hour, Zax has destroyed some myths." Caryn Rose, writing in
Pitchfork about the 38-CD
50th Anniversary Archive album, said "[T]he true revelation of this release is simply how great the newly restored recordings sound. Zax and Kehew approached the mixing by referring to photographic documentation, which allowed them to situate the performers within the mix based on where they were standing onstage. Comparing the original soundtrack to the 2019 product is like switching from black and white to Technicolor: The compression and flatness that choked the life out of the original release is gone. The result is a sonically welcoming experience that is as immersive as you could want; it is a joy to listen to."
Stephen Thomas Erlewine, writing on
AllMusic about the 10-CD
50th Anniversary Experience album, said "[Producer Andy] Zax's decision not to sweeten or fix the original tapes doesn't mean the set sounds rocky. On the contrary, the sound is vivid and alive, lending a kinetic kick to both rock bands and folk singers, yet it still sounds like a document of a specific time and place. ... [T]he whole weekend sounds exploratory and adventurous in a way that years of nostalgia have obscured." ==Track listing==