The Carnival was released to critical acclaim. In a contemporary review for
The Village Voice, music critic
Robert Christgau found the album more R&B than the "diasporan flavors" it uses as "half decoration, half concept", and remarked that Jean uses the
sampler for "one-dimensional tunes" that showcase his "well-articulated morality tales and popwise carnivalesque."
Stephen Thompson of
The A.V. Club, in a favorable review, called
The Carnival "a stunning solo album that's light years beyond
The Score". He also wrote "In his universalist embrace of music of all forms, Wyclef Jean makes a more powerful call for peace and unity than a thousand East Coast–West Coast 'Stop the violence, y'all' intros put together." Christgau, the poll's creator, ranked it twentieth on his own list. In 2011,
Rolling Stone ranked
The Carnival the 69th best album of the 1990s. == Commercial performance ==