The History of Homosexuality in China (Chinese, 1984, revised 1997) Context Xiaomingxiong first started working on his 1984 book
The History of Homosexuality when he was still in New York. With references to history, fiction, folktales, official court records, legal codes, religious documents, literature and arts, accounts by foreign missionaries, and even common slang and jokes, this book aimed to comprehensively record mentions of same-sex love in China. In writing
The History of Homosexuality (1984), Xiaomingxiong's main argument was to counter the belief that homosexuality was a "disease/sin brought from the West," claiming that same-sex love actually flourished in Chinese history and tradition and that it was actually
homophobia that was inherited from British rule. In the 1997 edition of
The History of Homosexuality, Xiaomingxiong made several revisions. Alongside more historical documentation, Xiaomingxiong added a preface providing contextual information regarding shifts in the social and political climate of Hong Kong in the 1980-90s. He amended his original claims; instead of arguing for "homophobia is a Western import," Xiaomingxiong argued that "existing homophobia in China was being Westernized." Scholar Helen Hok-Sze Leung states that the reason for this change was: [B]y the time the revised edition came…in 1997, the discursive relationship between homophobia, coloniality and nationalism had shifted considerably…[These] discursive shifts in Hong Kong society and the potential for nativist tendencies in
tongzhi discourse to be appropriated into a newly hegemonic Chinese nationalism prompts him [Xiaomingxiong] to reframe his understanding of homophobia in Hong Kong as a Westernized rather than Western phenomenon.Xiaomingxiong goes on to claim that Chinese homophobia, before Westernization, functioned through an implicit "fuzzy-
transgender-
transsexual pansexualism," in which same-sex love was accepted as long as there was a "transgender feminization" of a male partner and the "coexistance of
hetereosexual familial relationships." Leung further critiques this analysis, highlighting the reduction of transgender and
bisexual identities into homophobic "regulatory mechanisms" of homosexuality.
Controversy After the initial publication of
The History of Homosexuality (1984), Xiaomingxiong came across Bret Hinsch's book
Passions of the Cut Sleeve: The Male Homosexual Tradition in China (1992). After reading through the publication, Xiaomingxiong believed that some of the content and organization of Hinsch's book was similar to his. Though Xiaomingxiong reached out to Hinsch's publisher, no legal action was pursued due to his limited financial resources. ==Bibliography==