Legends .
Yue Fei is the second person from the left. This portrait is believed to be the "truest portrait of Yue in all extant materials." The earliest written records of xingyi can be traced to the 18th century, and are attributed to Ma Xueli of
Henan Province and
Dai Longbang of
Shanxi Province. Legend credits the creation of xingyi to renowned
Song dynasty (9601279 AD) general
Yue Fei, but this is disputed.
Yue Fei therefore did not, strictly speaking, invent xingyiquan, but synthesized and perfected existing Shaolin principles into his own style of gongfu which he popularized during his military service. Nonetheless, Yue Fei is usually identified as the creator because of his considerable understanding of the art (as shown in the work
The Ten Theses of Xingyiquan, credited to Yue) and his cultural status as a Chinese war hero. Some martial artists and
Chinese martial art historians hold that Yue's story is largely legendary. While xingyiquan may well have evolved from military spear techniques, there is no supporting evidence to show that Yue Fei was involved or that the art dates to the Song dynasty. These authors point out that the works attributed to Yue Fei long postdate his life, some being as recent as the
Republican era, and that it was common practice in China to attribute new works to a famous or legendary person, rather than take credit for oneself. In addition, historical memoirs and scholarly research papers only mention
Zhou Tong teaching Yue archery and not spear play. Yue historically learned spear play from Chen Guang (陳廣), who was hired by the boy's paternal grandfather, Yao Daweng (姚大翁). Beginning in the late Ming era, the evidence for the art's history grows clearer.
Ji Longfeng, also known as Ji Jike, is the first person generally agreed to have both existed and practiced the art. Ji Longfeng's contributions to the art are described in the
Ji Clan Chronicles (姬氏族譜;
pinyin: Ji Shi Zupu). The
Chronicles describe xingyiquan as a martial art based on the combat principles of the spear. The
Chronicles attribute this stylistic influence to Ji himself, who was known as the "Divine Spear" (神槍;
pinyin: Shén Qiāng) for his extraordinary skill with the weapon. Nowadays, many believe that the style Ji Longfeng was taught had been
Shaolin Xinyiba (a style which still exists today, and bears some resemblance to
xinyi liuhequan). Ji Longfeng referred to his art as
liuhe, The Six Harmonies, a reference to the most highly developed spear style practiced in the late
Ming military.
Li Luoneng was proficient in other martial arts before studying Dai-style Xinyi. Some claim his original art was
qimenquan (奇門拳), perhaps his family's style, while others believe he actually studied
tongbeiquan and
gongliquan. Li came to study under the Dai family either because he heard of their fame in the martial arts and business, or maybe as suggested by others, after having fought and lost to a practitioner of their art. It is generally agreed that he then settled in the area of their village, and grew and sold vegetables, which earned him the nickname "Li Laonong" (李老農, literally "Old Farmer Li", but with the connotation of "Respectable Farmer Li"). Initially, members of the Dai clan refused to teach him, but he eventually won over their trust, and he was taught by Dai Wenxiong, Guo Weihan, or both. After learning Dai-style Xinyi for a number of years, perhaps over a decade, Li left the Dai territories and traveled across Shanxi and Hebei provinces, teaching for many years his own elaboration on the art, now called "
xingyiquan". No reasons were ever recorded for the many changes Li made to the art, but there are those who claim that Li wished to compete with the Dai clan's fame, perhaps because of some grudge. Li and many of his students and grand-students were famous for offering bodyguard and caravan escort services.
Recent history (20th and 21st centuries) A condensed version of xingyiquan was taught to Chinese officers at the Military Academy at Nanjing during the
Second Sino-Japanese War for
close quarters combat. This included armed techniques – such as bayonet and sabre drills – alongside unarmed techniques.
Sun Lutang became famous in the early 20th century for his skills (chiefly in the
Beijing and
Tianjin areas), and for the martial books he wrote about the
Internal arts. During Sun Lutang's lifetime and martial career, he and several of his contemporaries began to classify xingyi, together with
tai chi and
baguazhang, as the "
Wudang" style of martial arts. which came down from
Zhang Junfeng. Many of Zhang's students and grand-students, such as
Kenneth Fish (martial artist),
Hung I-Hsiang,
Su Dongchen,
Luo Dexiu,
Hsu Hung-chi and others have taught his xingyi to Westerners since the 1980s – especially Americans. This branch became the most popular because Taiwan was open to Westerners during the 20th century, while throughout much of that century, the People's Republic of China did not allow Westerners to visit regularly, and thus people were not exposed to branches of the art from the mainland. Contrary to popular belief, spread by some Taiwanese teachers, the art had not 'died out' on the mainland, but was simply inaccessible to outsiders for several decades. Another popular Taiwanese branch in the West is
Wang Shujin's lineage, which was chiefly transmitted by his student Wang Fulai. There are also several lineages from
Tianjin which are nowadays taught in the West, namely in
Canada and
Israel. Lines of Dai-style xingyi and xingyi liuhe are still rare in the West, and can be said to even be relatively rare in China, though they are not at risk of becoming 'extinct'. In the United States, Dai-style xingyi is taught by
Li Tailiang and several of his students.
Yiquan, on the other hand, has become exceedingly popular in the West, being taught in many schools, especially in Europe. There are no statistics as to the number of practitioners in any of these arts in either China or other countries.
Disputed history Ancient Chinese texts, like those which make up the "Xingyi Classics", often contain characters whose meanings are obscure or have disappeared completely from the Chinese language. Specialized terms which describe historically specific concepts (e.g. names of ancient weapons) are commonly interpreted with reference to their closest, modern linguistic equivalent. The results can be problematic, producing translations which are linguistically correct but inconsistent within a fighting or martial context. The recognized founder of
baguazhang,
Dong Haichuan, was reputed to have fought
Guo Yunshen with neither able to defeat the other – though it is possible that they were training together. It would have been controversial at the time for Dong Haichuan to have studied under
Guo Yunshen, since Dong was the older of the two. The most neutral viewpoint would be to say that they trained
together, which may explain the stylistic similarities between
baguazhang and the xingyiquan monkey shape.
Frantzis argues that this encounter never took place and that Guo and Dong had little contact with each other. Frantzis argues that a
xingyi-bagua exchange was more likely to have occurred in
Tianjin c. 1900 where xingyi masters Li Cunyi and Zhang Zhaodong, bagua master Cheng Tinghua, and four other xingyi and
bagua teachers lived together (Frantzis, 1998, p. 179). Sun Lutang states in his autobiography that the legendary fight between
Guo Yunshen and Dong Haichuan never happened. The book states that the truth of the matter is that
Guo Yunshen actually fought one of his older xingyi brothers and lost. Sun Lutang was a student of both
Guo Yunshen and Cheng Tinghua so this understanding on the subject seems to be one of the most accurate. Treating the story of Dong Haichuan and Guo Yunshen as allegory, however, reveals a common training protocol among xingyiquan and
baguazhang practitioners. Often, because
baguazhang requires significantly more time for a practitioner's skill to mature, it is acceptable to learn xingyiquan first or simultaneously. Such a practitioner develops a tactical vocabulary that is more readily apparent than the core baguazhang movements. Another debated question in this regard is the identity of the teacher of Li Luoneng, the founder of modern xingyiquan. It is known that Li studied with the Dai clan, but remains unclear who taught him. Some people and lineages have traditionally claimed that he was taught by master Dai Longbang. However, many others point to the fact that Longbang died before Luoneng was born, or when Luoneng was quite young. Combined with the fact that Luoneng only arrived at Dai territory as a traveling adult, others argue that it would have been impossible for him to have studied under Longbang, and suggest his teacher was actually Longbang's student,
Guo Weihan. Another historical controversy relates to the identity of the teacher of the founder of
yiquan, late master
Wang Xiangzhai (~1886–1963). Most
yiquan oral traditions have it that
Guo Yunshen, a student of the founder of modern xingyi (Li Luoneng), had been Wang Xiangzhai's teacher. However, since Wang was not yet alive (or was a young child) at the time of
Guo Yunshen's death, others suggest he must have learnt from Guo's other disciples (
Li Bao 李豹 is thought to have been his true main teacher). The chart below lists
Li Bao as Wang's teacher, and
Guo Yunshen as an indirect teacher due to the controversy surrounding the matter (until further historical evidence surfaces). ==Branches==