Chronological position The dynasty to which Yaqub-Har belongs is debated, with Yaqub-Har being seen variously as a 14th Dynasty king, an early
Hyksos ruler of the 15th Dynasty or a vassal of the Hyksos kings.
Fourteenth Dynasty The
14th Dynasty of Egypt has ruled the eastern Delta region just prior to the arrival of the Hyksos in Egypt. The Danish specialist
Kim Ryholt has suggested that Yaqub-Har was a king of the late 14th Dynasty and the last one of this dynasty to be known from contemporary attestations. Since the name "Yaqub-Har" may have a
West Semitic origin, meaning "Protected by
Har", Yaqub-Har would then be a 14th Dynasty ruler. Ryholt's argument is based on the observation that while early
Hyksos kings of the 15th Dynasty, such as
Sakir-Har, used the title
Heka-Khawaset, later Hyksos rulers adopted the traditional Egyptian royal titulary. This change happened under
Khyan, who ruled as the
Heka-Khawaset early in his reign, but later adopted the Egyptian prenomen
Seuserenre. Later Hyksos kings, such as
Apophis, abandoned the
Heka-Khawaset title and retained instead the customary Egyptian prenomen, just like the kings of the 14th Dynasty. Ryholt then notes that Yaqub-Har himself always used a
prenomen,
Meruserre, which suggests that he either ruled at the end of the 15th Dynasty or was a member of the 14th Dynasty. Since the end of the 15th Dynasty is known not to have included a ruler by the name of Meruserre, Ryholt concludes that Yaqub-Har was a 14th Dynasty ruler.
Fifteenth Dynasty and Yaqub-Har, Petrie, "The Making of Egypt" On the other hand, Daphna Ben-Tor and Suzanne Allen note that Yaqub-Har's scarab seals are stylistically almost identical with those of the well-attested Hyksos king
Khyan. This suggests that Yaqub-Har was either Khyan's immediate
15th Dynasty successor or a vassal of the Hyksos king who ruled a part of the Egyptian Delta under Khyan's authority. As Ben-Tor writes, "Supporting evidence for the Fifteenth Dynasty affiliation of King Yaqubhar is provided by the close stylistic similarity between his scarabs and the scarabs of King
Khayan". Additionally, the form of the
wsr-sign used in these kings' royal prenomina "argue for a chronological proximity [between Yaqub-Har and Khyan] and against Ryholt's assigning of Yaqub-Har to the Fourteenth Dynasty and Khayan to the Fifteenth Dynasty." ==Popular speculation==