Lipkin was known as the father of the
Musar movement that developed, particularly among the Lithuanian Jews, in 19th century Orthodox Eastern Europe. The Hebrew term musar (מוּסַר), is from the book of Proverbs 1:2 meaning instruction, discipline, or conduct. The term was used by the Musar movement to refer to disciplined efforts to further ethical and spiritual development. The study of Musar is a part of the study of Jewish ethics. Lipkin is best known for stressing that the inter-personal laws of the
Torah bear as much weight as other Divine obligations. According to Lipkin, adhering to the ritual aspects of Judaism without developing one's relationships with others and oneself was an unpardonable parody. There are many anecdotal stories about him that relate to this moral equation, see for example the following references. The concept of the
unconscious appears in the writings of Lipkin well before the concept was popularized by
Sigmund Freud, though its discussion predates Lipkin as well. Already in 1880, the concept of conscious and subconscious processes and the role they play in the psychological, emotional and moral functioning of man are fully developed and elucidated. These concepts are referred to in his works as the "outer"
[chitzoniut] and "inner"
[penimiut] processes, they are also referred to as the "clear"
[klarer] and "dark"
[dunkler] processes. They form a fundamental building block of many of Rabbi Salanter's letters, essays and teachings. He would write that it is critical for a person to recognize what his subconscious motivations
[negiot] are and to work on understanding them. Lipkin would teach that the time for a person to work on not allowing improper subconscious impulses to affect him was during times of emotional quiet, when a person is more in control of his thoughts and feelings. He would stress that when a person is experiencing an acute emotional response to an event, he is not necessarily in control of his thoughts and faculties and will not have access to the calming perspectives necessary to allow his conscious mind to intercede. Based on his understanding of subconscious motivation, Lipkin was faced with a quandary. Given that a person's subconscious motivations are often not apparent or under the control of a person and are likely to unseat conscious decisions that they may make, how is it then possible for a person to control and modify their own actions in order to improve their actions and act in accordance with the dictates of the
Torah? If the basis of a person's actions are not controlled by them, how can they change them through conscious thought? Lipkin argued that the only solution to this dilemma is to study ethical teachings with intense emotion [''limud hamusar behispa'alut
]. He taught that a person should choose an ethical statement [ma'amar chazal''] and repeat this over and over with great feeling and concentration on its meaning. Through this repetition and internal arousal, a person would be able to bring the idea represented in the ethical teaching into the realm of his subconscious and thus improve their behaviour and "character traits". Lipkin felt that people would be embarrassed to study ethical teachings [''limud ha'musar
] in such a way in a normal study-hall [bet ha'medrash
] and he therefore invented the idea of a "house of ethical teachings" [bet ha'mussar''] that would be located next to an ordinary study hall and that would be designated for learning ethics in this way. One of the more popular teachings of Lipkin is based on a real life encounter he had with a shoemaker one very late night. It was
Motza'ei Shabbat (Saturday night after Shabbat) and Lipkin was on the way to the
synagogue to recite
Selichot. Suddenly he felt a tear in his shoe, so he looked around town to see if there was a shoemaker still open for business at this late hour. Finally he located a shoemaker sitting in his shop working next to his candle. Lipkin walked in and asked him, "Is it too late now to get my shoes repaired?" The shoemaker replied, "As long as the candle is burning, it is still possible to repair." Upon hearing this, Lipkin ran to the synagogue and preached to the public what he had learned from the shoemaker. In his words, as long as the candle is burning, as long as one is still alive, it is still possible to repair one's soul. ==Famous disciples==