British journalists reviewing the world premiere expressed a mixture of bewilderment and scorn. Writing in
The Times,
Stanley Sadie said, "Criticism is impotent on such a work as this; there is nothing to do but describe". He nevertheless concluded by comparing
Ylem unfavourably to earlier works by the composer on the programme (
Kreuzspiel,
Zeitmaße, and
Kontra-Punkte), which "made his latest piece sound, rightly or wrongly, like Nirvana-hungry doodlings".
Paul Griffiths felt that the newest work on the programme,
Ylem, "provided the least newness". Although "there was occasional interest in the responding calls across the hall … the overall process is simplistic—an idea that could well have been left to
Xenakis". Where Sadie found contrasts to Stockhausen's earlier works, New Zealand composer and writer
Robin Maconie perceives similarities:
Spiel (1952),
Gruppen (1955–57),
Kontakte (1958–60),
Momente (1962–64/69), the moment titled "Translation" in
Mixtur (1964),
Adieu (1966), the "Russian Bridge" in the Third Region of
Hymnen with orchestra (1966–67/69),
Intervall for piano four-hands (1969), and the
Dr K–Sextett (1969) all share with
Ylem the technique of gradual dispersal or condensation (or both) of constellations of tones. American film and television critic
David Lavery's response to what he calls "the strangest piece of
program music ever composed" was more visceral: Explaining his personal reaction in the context of a recurring childhood nightmare of
nothingness, Lavery invokes a similar idea underlying
H. P. Lovecraft's short story "
The Music of Erich Zann" and sensations described in passages from
Georges Poulet,
Rainer Maria Rilke,
Herman Melville,
Claude Lévi-Strauss,
Paul Valéry,
R. Murray Schafer, and the
Śūraṅgama Sūtra. Finding that
Ylem represents the
Vedic "unstruck sound of the celestial realm" or
anahata nad, Lavery concludes that it is representative of Stockhausen's
moment form, "music made out of nothing, one of Stockhausen's most effective attempts to create a 'sequence of silences'". The 1973 BBC broadcast inspired the then 15-year old
Andrew Ford to become a composer. ==Discography==