You Are OK was met with positive reviews from music critics. Timothy Monger of
AllMusic described the album's sound as an, "increasingly slick contemporary pop territory with big melodic choruses, loads of hooks, and a more varied palette of sounds." Sam Devotta of
idobi praised the band for consistently mixing up their sound and rewarded the album a 10 out of 10 rating. Jack Press of
Upset stated that the album is, "by far the most confident album The Maine have made, stacking risk after risk up on a pedestal from EDM-wrapped orchestral strings ('Numb Without You') to nine-minute alt-prog jams ('Flowers On The Grave'). A negative review came from
Sputnikmusic remarking, "
You Are OKs main problem: The Maine are at their most ambitious, I guess, but in the wrong ways. Production flourishes and a new song structure hamper their strengths here [...] The Maine best go back and start caring about the right things and who they are as a band." ==Track listing==