"You Found Me" debuted at number 28 on the
Billboard Hot 100, making it the band's highest debut on the chart to date. On February 7, 2009, issue of
Billboard magazine, the single jumped to number eight on the strength of a 91% digital single sales increase from the previous week and steady airplay gains on several radio formats, becoming the Fray's third Billboard Hot 100 top ten hit after "
Over My Head (Cable Car)" and "
How to Save a Life". It peaked at number seven, their second highest peaking song on the chart. On the
Hot Adult Top 40 Tracks chart, the song reached number one, making it their third top five hit and second number one on that chart. The song reached 3 million in downloads in the US by October 2011, and has sold 3.6 million copies as of January 2015. On the
Canadian Hot 100 it debuted at number 51, and jumped to number 13 the following week also based on sales strength and would go on to peak at number 12 in mid-February. In the United Kingdom, the song reached number 35. In its first week on the
Australian ARIA Singles Chart, the song debuted at number 998 and peaked at number one. It marks the Fray's first ever number-one song in Australia and second top-ten hit after "How to Save a Life". The Fray held this spot for four weeks until
Flo Rida's "
Right Round" knocked it off the top spot. More than two and a half years since exiting the ARIA Top 50, it returned to the chart at No. 50 for the week starting November 28, 2011, on the back of
The X Factor Australia runner-up
Andrew Wishart collaborated with the Fray on the show's grand finale. ==B-side==