In 1994, French DJ
Laurent Garnier named "You Make Me Feel (Mighty Real)" one of his favourites of all time, saying, "Amazing powerful
hi-NRG. He's got a wicked voice — the vocals are beautiful, more than anything else he's done. I heard first in Italy around the time of
Donna Summer's '
I Feel Love'." In October 2000,
VH1 ranked it No. 14 in their list of "100 Greatest Dance Songs". In 2003,
Q Magazine ranked it No. 677 in their list of the "1001 Best Songs Ever". In 2019, the song was selected by the
Library of Congress for preservation in the
National Recording Registry for being "culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant". In 2020,
Daily Mirror ranked "You Make Me Feel (Mighty Real)" No. 13 in their "Top 50 Happiest Songs Ever" list. In 2021,
Rolling Stone included it in their list of "
500 Best Songs of All Time" at No. 399. In 2022, they ranked it No. 39 in their list of "200 Greatest Dance Songs of All Time". The same year,
Time Out ranked it No. 8 in their list of "The 50 Best Gay Songs to Celebrate Pride All Year Long". In October 2023,
Billboard ranked "You Make Me Feel (Mighty Real)" No. 428 in their "Best
Pop Songs of All Time". In March 2025,
Billboard ranked it No. 17 in their list of "The 100 Best Dance Songs of All Time", while in June same year, it was ranked No. 2 in their "The 100 Greatest LGBTQ+ Anthems of All Time". ==Charts==