Album of the Year rates the consensus at 81 with four reviews. The editorial staff of
AllMusic gave the album 4.5 out of five stars, with reviewer
Stephen Thomas Erlewine summing up that it's "an album that feels like a classic not just through its sound but through its depth of feeling". For
Slate, Carl Wilson wrote that the release is Clark's "most personal album" yet and praises the maturity of her songwriting: "Clark has mostly left behind the exercises in women-empowerment snark and spunk that her previous records leaned on for infusions of energy, a recourse that's become its own cliché in women’s country". In a brief preview for the week in country,
Billboard highlighted the release, with Annie Reuter calling Clark's "adept songwriting" the center of the album; the publication later had a full review from Tom Roland who compared this album with Clarks's previous ones to find it the most authentic songwriting and performance of her career. In assessing the album, Clark's career, and the general state of contemporary country music,
The New Yorkers David Cantwell declared that "no one is writing better country songs than Brandy Clark is" and that this third album is her finest. In
American Songwriter, Jason Scott gave the album 4.5 out of five, joining voices calling it her finest release, explaining Clark's strength as musician as well as producer
Jay Joyce's ability to augment her voice. A more mixed review came from
Pitchforks Sam Sodomsky, rating the album 7.5 out of 10, praising innovative arrangements and incisive and clever lyrics that will challenge listeners. Reviewing the album for
Exclaim!, Kyle Mullin gave the release a seven out of 10, noting the same qualities and suggesting that other songwriters will "daydream about following in her footsteps". Chris Willman of
Variety calls Clark as a songwriter "
the necessary next stop [after the success of
Kacey Musgraves] for anyone joining this program already in progress and finding that Music City is the richest source of fingerpicking female singer-songwriters with crystalline voices, classic twang-pop sensibilities and a knack for sweet devastation" and gives a positive review of this album for its myriad looks at relationships. ==Track listing==