George Harrison received favourable reviews from music critics. Harry George of the
NME wrote that Harrison's happiness with Arias had seemingly replaced Krishna as a muse and had reinvigorated his music. He said that the album succeeded on Harrison's "guileless romanticism" in tracks where "Crafty harmonies and skilfully-layered guitars recall the sun-soaked vistas of 'Because' and '
Sun King' on
Abbey Road." Writing in
Melody Maker,
E.J. Thribb admired Harrison for bringing "both sunshine and moonshine into our lives" and recognised "Your Love Is Forever" as a song with the artist's "[trademark] chiming guitar chords" and "ringing sincerity" in the vocals. Reviewing the 2004 reissues of Harrison's Dark Horse Records catalogue, for
Blender,
Paul Du Noyer named the song as the first of the "standout tracks" on
George Harrison, which he described as the product of Harrison's "twin retreats of tropical Hawaii and rural England, reflecting a man content to let the rock & roll mainstream pass him by". James Griffiths of
The Guardian paired "Your Love Is Forever" with the 1981 devotional "
Life Itself" as two "transcendentally lovely" songs, and examples of how Harrison's Dark Horse releases were often unjustly overlooked. Writing in
The Rolling Stone Album Guide that same year, Mac Randall said that "mellowness overwhelms musicality" on
George Harrison, although he made an exception of "
Not Guilty" and the "understated gem" "Your Love Is Forever". On the occasion of the album's 40th anniversary in 2019, Morgan Enos of
Billboard described "Your Love Is Forever" as one of the songs that "waft[ed] in from the rainforest air" on Maui, adding that it was a "droning, ambient love ballad to Olivia" that "practically invented
Cocteau Twins". Thomas MacFarlane writes of Harrison's success in fusing Western and Eastern musical elements in the song: "Certain musical moments can only be described as miraculous. When such moments are created through the medium of sound recording, they become gifts that continue to fascinate and inspire." In his song review for
AllMusic, Lindsay Planer views it as a standout of what he calls "Harrison’s vital and almost blasphemously underappreciated late 1970s/early 1980s catalogue". Lindsay admires the melody and lyrics, including the "beautifully pastoral imagery of the ebb and flow of seasonal changes", and the atmosphere created by the electric and slide guitars and supported by Newmark's understated drumming. Deeming it "George Harrison's musical image of heaven", with a slide guitar solo that "reveals exquisite lyricism", Leng views the song as the clearest example of Harrison sharing the aesthetic forwarded by American composer
Alan Hovhaness earlier in the twentieth century, when Hovhaness, similarly drawing inspiration from Eastern music and religion, bucked prevailing trends by steadfastly celebrating melody over
atonality. Ian Inglis includes "Your Love Is Forever" among the Harrison songs that possess "great charm, energy, and beauty" yet may be little known compared with those from the artist's most critically acclaimed albums. Inglis calls it a "beautifully controlled track" and an example of how, similar to the surge in the Beatles' productivity during their
1968 visit to Rishikesh in India, Harrison's first Maui holiday released a "vein of sophisticated and delicate music that was previously hidden". ==Personnel==