Despite the attractiveness of the aldol manifold, there are several problems that need to be addressed to render the process effective. The first problem is a thermodynamic one: most aldol reactions are reversible. Furthermore, the equilibrium is also just barely on the side of the products in the case of simple aldehyde–ketone aldol reactions. A key distinction is whether the conditions
dehydrate the product to an
enone. In mild conditions (e.g., LDA (a strong base), THF, −78 °C), the (hydrated) product is a
aldol, and the base catalyzes retro-aldol cleavage of the product. The reaction must be
driven by e.g. distillation. Under harsher conditions (e.g.: NaOMe/MeOH/
reflux), the product dehydrates practically irreversibly, and the reaction completes spontaneously. Hydration followed by retro-aldol cleavage is possible, but rare without dedicated catalysis. Dehydration is also the catalytic strategy of
class I aldolases and numerous
small-molecule amine catalysts. When a mixture of unsymmetrical ketones are reacted, four crossed-aldol (
addition) products can be anticipated: To obtain only one product, one must control which carbonyl becomes the nucleophilic enol/enolate and which remains in its electrophilic carbonyl form. The simplest control occurs when only one reactant has acidic protons: that molecule must enolize. For example, the addition of
diethyl malonate into
benzaldehyde produces only one product: If one group is considerably more acidic than the other, the most acidic proton is abstracted by the base. An enolate is formed at that carbonyl while the less-acidic carbonyl remains electrophilic. This type of control works only if the difference in acidity is large enough and base is the
limiting reactant. A typical substrate for this situation is when the deprotonatable position is activated by more than one carbonyl-like group. Common examples include a CH2 group flanked by two carbonyls or nitriles (see for example the
Knoevenagel condensation and the first steps of the
malonic ester synthesis and
acetoacetic ester synthesis). Otherwise, the most acidic carbonyls are typically also the most active electrophiles: first
aldehydes, then
ketones, then
esters, and finally
amides. Thus cross-aldehyde reactions are typically most challenging because they can
polymerize easily or react unselectively to give a statistical mixture of products. One common solution assumes
kinetic control. In that case, the forward aldol addition is significantly faster than the retro-aldol reverse and faster than enolate transfer from one partner to another. Thus one can first form the desired partner's enolate
quantitatively, then simply add the other partner. Common kinetic control conditions involve ketone enolization with
LDA at −78 °C, followed by the slow addition of an aldehyde. == Stereoselectivity ==