Box office 1492: Conquest of Paradise opened on 66 screens in Spain, grossing $1million in its first five days The film was a
flop in the United States, debuting at number7 with a gross of $3,002,680 (about $million today), worse than the opening of
Christopher Columbus: The Discovery earlier in the year, and went on to gross just $7million ($million today). It opened in France on 12October 1992, grossing $1.46million for the weekend ($million today) from 264screens. In its second week in Europe, it was the highest-grossing film with a gross of over $7.7million ($million today), including $1.77million in its opening week in Germany ($million today) from 213screens. It did not open well in Italy, with only $261,800 in its opening weekend ($ today) from 33screens. By the end of 1992, it had grossed $40million internationally ($million today),, including $17 million in France and €3 million in Spain, for a worldwide total of $47million ($million today). It went on to gross $59million ($million today). Director Ridley Scott later blamed the movie's failure on Americans not understanding European accents: "They don't hear shit unless it's from Texas or America, right?" and reflected: "It's one of my favorite films. What's interesting, they didn't know how to release it in America. But in Europe, it clocked $57 million." In 2024, he give a similar statement: "I'm very proud of
1492, with Gérard Depardieu. The problem with Gérard is he doesn't speak very good English and I didn't have the heart to say, 'Gérard we need to [re-record all your lines].' I'm trying to resurrect
1492 because it's so beautifully shot and acted and scored. I'm trying to resurrect it as a four-hour [movie] for a streaming platform. Now if I asked, 'Gérard, can we ADR you with Kenneth Branagh?' he'd probably say, 'Yeah, of course.
Critical response Overall,
1492: Conquest of Paradise received mixed to negative reviews from critics, with the review aggregator
Rotten Tomatoes giving the film a 30% rating based on 23 reviews with the critical consensus: "Historically inaccurate and dramatically inert, Ridley Scott's retelling of Christopher Columbus' exploits is an epic without grandeur or insight". However, film critic
Roger Ebert said that the film was satisfactory, and that "Depardieu lends it gravity, the supporting performances are convincing, the locations are realistic, and we are inspired to reflect that it did indeed take a certain nerve to sail off into nowhere just because an orange was round." Audiences surveyed by
CinemaScore gave the film a grade of "B+" on scale of A+ to F. In a more typical review of the day,
Desson Howe of
The Washington Post said that "despite Scott's trademark, spectacular imagery, the story's dead in the water. Actually, there's no story. It's all eye-dizzying hyperbole, with astounding camerawork, fancy editing and a moody flamenco guitar-meets-synthesizer soundtrack by avant-garde musician Vangelis." A reviewer for
Variety wrote that "Ridley Scott's vaunted visuals can't transform
1492 from a lumbering, one-dimensional historical fresco into the complex, ambiguous character study that it strives to be." Chris Hicks of the
Salt Lake City-based
Deseret News wrote that "Scott, the accomplished director of '
Alien,' '
Blade Runner' and '
Thelma & Louise,' among others, has imbued this film with great visual style, and the sets, costumes and general atmosphere are fascinating. In fact, there is much to recommend on a technical level. But '1492' is, unfortunately, plagued with narrative problems that make it a less than successful cinematic voyage."
Owen Gleiberman of
Entertainment Weekly wrote that "at 2.5 hours,
1492 is even harder to sit through than last month’s schlock extravaganza
Christopher Columbus: The Discovery. In each case the filmmakers have fallen into a similar trap. Out of some vague mixture of historical 'duty' and commercial myopia, they’ve presented Columbus as the same cardboard visionary we learned about in school. Whether or not that image has a core of truth, are there really many people who want to experience it all over again at the movies? Watching 1492 is about as exciting as doing your homework." The film was accused of promoting the
Spanish black legend. ==See also==