August to December Burnley's First Division campaign began with a 3–2 win over
Leeds United at
Elland Road on 22 August, with goals from
Brian Pilkington,
John Connelly, and
Ray Pointer. Ahead of Burnley's first home match of the season at
Turf Moor against
Everton, Potts wrote in the club's
matchday programme: "We pride ourselves on being a footballing team and no club can be more eager to meet the demand for better play". The team defeated Everton 5–2, but then lost 3–1 at home to
West Ham United, despite taking the lead through Connelly. Burnley lost the fixture 1–0 but Elder played well against Preston's
England international
Tom Finney and remained in the starting line-up. Both sides were missing key players—Spurs were without
Dave Mackay and
Danny Blanchflower, while McIlroy, Burnley's
playmaker, was still absent. The match ended in a 1–1
draw, after defender
Brian Miller equalised for Burnley in the 87th minute. Burnley then faced Lancashire rivals
Blackpool at home; Burnley took the lead through Robson but the visitors scored four goals to win 4–1. Before the
East Lancashire derby at
Blackburn Rovers on 17 October, Potts received criticism from the Burnley supporters who objected to his "confusing playing style", such as the defenders switching positions during matches. Against Blackburn, Burnley equalised twice, but the hosts scored a third goal to win 3–2. On 7 November, Burnley defeated Wolverhampton Wanderers 4–1 at Turf Moor; Wolves were the First Division champions of the previous two seasons. The team kept their first
clean sheet of the season, With McIlroy absent, Burnley hosted last-place Leeds United on 19 December in front of a season-lowest crowd of 17,398. Leeds won 1–0 and Burnley slipped down from third to fourth place in the table, three points behind leaders Tottenham.
January to May The team's first match of 1960 resulted in a 5–2 victory away at title contenders West Ham. The
Sunday Pictorial concluded: "If they go on playing like this they'll soon have nobody above them". Burnley then defeated Chelsea 2–1 on a snowy Turf Moor pitch and drew 0–0 with West Brom to end January in second place in the table. On 1 March, the team recorded a 2–0 home win over league leaders Tottenham to close the gap to three points, but with two games in hand on Spurs. The following game, at home against
Sheffield Wednesday, ended in a 3–3 draw after Miller equalised for Burnley in the 88th minute. Potts moved Adamson to the
centre-half position to partner Cummings, while Miller was placed in
midfield. The team recorded three consecutive wins: Forest and Leicester City were both defeated 1–0, while Burnley beat Luton 3–0 despite only having 10 men for most of the game, after Pointer came off injured. Connelly scored the winning goal against Leicester, his 20th league goal of the season, but picked up a
cartilage injury during the match and was out for the remainder of the season; he was replaced by
Trevor Meredith. Blacklaw returned in goal for the match against Birmingham City on 27 April, while Cummings, McIlroy and Miller also played despite having minor injuries; Burnley won 1–0 after a late goal from Pilkington. Burnley were crowned First Division champions for the second time, and won their first
top flight title in 39 years. The
Daily Mirror noted: "Burnley, the team of quiet men—five of them are part-timers and the whole outfit cost less than £15,000—snatched the First Division Championship from the teeth of the famous Wolves". The team won the title with one of the lowest post-war point tallies (55), one of the smallest goal averages (1.39), and one of the highest numbers of goals conceded (61).
Match results ;Key • In result column, Burnley's score shown first • H = Home match • A = Away match • pen. =
Penalty kick • o.g. =
Own goal ;Results Source: ==FA Cup==