First quarter The Chiefs struck first with a 24-yard field goal by
Jan Stenerud. Following an interception by
Willie Lanier of
Bob Griese and 17 yard return,
Len Dawson threw a 7-yard touchdown pass to
Ed Podolak, increasing the Chiefs' lead to 10–0.
Second quarter Following the Chiefs' touchdown, on the Dolphins' next drive, Griese completed a 23-yard pass to
Paul Warfield and a 16-yard pass to
Marv Fleming to set up a 1-yard touchdown run by
Larry Csonka, narrowing the Chiefs' lead to 10–7. A Podolak fumble deep in Chiefs territory was recovered by the Dolphins' defense, allowing for a 14-yard field goal by
Garo Yepremian to tie the game at 10–10 shortly before halftime.
Third quarter Following a 10-minute, 15-play, 75-yard drive culminating in a 1-yard touchdown run by
Jim Otis, the Chiefs retook a 17–10 lead. The Dolphins answered with a 1-yard touchdown run from
Jim Kiick to retie the game at 17–17.
Fourth quarter Dolphins linebacker
Nick Buoniconti recovered a fumble to give them a scoring opportunity before Chiefs linebacker
Jim Lynch intercepted Griese on the Chiefs' 9-yard line. Following a 91-yard drive that included a 63-yard pass to rookie wide receiver
Elmo Wright, The Chiefs retook a 24–17 lead with a 3-yard touchdown run by Podolak. The Dolphins immediately rattled off a 71-yard drive with passes by Griese to Warfield of 17 and 26 yards culminating with a 5-yard touchdown pass to Fleming, tying the game at 24–24 with under two minutes left in regulation. Podolak returned the kickoff 78 yards to the Dolphins' 22-yard line, opening the door for Stenerud to kick a game-winning field goal for the Chiefs in the final minute of regulation. However, he missed the 31-yarder wide right, allowing the Dolphins to regain possession. The Chiefs defense was able to force the Dolphins to punt as time expired. The Chiefs elected to not attempt a 68-yard
fair catch kick, fearing a return by
Mercury Morris, sending the game to overtime.
Overtime The Chiefs won the coin toss and received the opening kickoff of the first overtime period, with Podolak returning it to the 46-yard line. The Chiefs got into scoring range, but Stenerud's 42-yard field goal attempt was blocked. The Chiefs defense forced the Dolphins to punt, before the Dolphins defense forced a Chiefs punt on a three-and-out. The Dolphins advanced the ball to the Chiefs' 45-yard line where Yepremian attempted a 52-yard field goal, but it was short. The Chiefs advanced the ball to midfield before Dawson threw a pass deep in Dolphins' territory that was intercepted by Dolphins safety
Jake Scott and returned to the 46-yard line as the clock expired, sending the game to a second overtime for the first time in NFL playoff history (prior to the
AFL–NFL merger, the
1962 American Football League Championship Game went to a second overtime).
Second overtime Following the interception, the Chiefs defense forced a Dolphins punt on a three-and-out. During the drive, as the clock went down past 12:06 during a tackle for loss of Podolak by
Manny Fernandez on second down, the game became the longest game in professional football history, a record it still holds to this day. Podolak got the yards back on third down, but the Chiefs were still held to a punt, which was fair caught at the 30-yard line by Scott.
Game-winning drive Following the fair catch, Kiick ran for 5 yards to advance the Dolphins to the 35-yard line. Csonka then took off for 29 yards to put the Dolphins in Chiefs' territory at their 36-yard line. Following a 2-yard run by Kiick, 4-yard run by Csonka, and run for no gain by Kiick, the Dolphins faced fourth down at the Chiefs' 30-yard line, setting up a field goal attempt by Yepremian. Yepremian made the ensuing 37-yard field goal at 7:40 into the second overtime, ending the longest game in NFL history at 82 minutes, 40 seconds with a 27–24 win for the Dolphins.
Box Score == Aftermath ==