Cleveland Browns The
Cleveland Browns selected Warfield with the 11th pick of the
1964 NFL draft. There was some thought for Warfield to play as a defensive back. But during workouts prior to the season, his play as a
wide receiver impressed head coach
Blanton Collier, and he was converted to the position. In his rookie season, he caught 52 passes for 920 yards and nine touchdowns. He averaged 17.8 yards per reception, and his speed served to complement the power of star running back
Jim Brown. Warfield was invited to his first
Pro Bowl and was named a first-team
All-Pro by the
Newspaper Enterprise Association (NEA). The Browns returned to the
NFL Championship Game in 1965, in which Warfield caught two passes for 30 yards in a 23–12 loss to the
Green Bay Packers. Warfield returned to form in 1966, catching 36 passes for 741 yards and five touchdowns, and in 1967 recorded 32 receptions for 702 yards and eight touchdowns. In 1968, Warfield caught 50 passes and for the only time in his career eclipsed 1,000 receiving yards, finishing with 1,067. His career-high 12 receiving touchdowns led the league that year. The Browns again reached
the NFL Championship Game, where they were shutout by the
Baltimore Colts, 34–0. Warfield earned first-team All-Pro honors from the
Associated Press (AP),
United Press International (UPI),
Pro Football Weekly, and NEA, and made another Pro Bowl appearance. The trade came as a shock to Warfield, who had established himself as one of the Browns' most popular players. "I have to admit going to Miami was not a place I desired to go," said Warfield 30 years later. The Browns used the pick acquired in the trade on
Purdue University quarterback
Mike Phipps. The trade is considered one of the most lopsided in NFL history, as Phipps had only limited success for the Browns, while Warfield was a major factor in the Dolphins' championships in the early 1970s.
Miami Dolphins In need of a deep-play receiver, Dolphins head coach
Don Shula stated he "jumped at the chance" to acquire Warfield, saying he had always admired him and called him "a real thoroughbred, equal to the best in the game." In his first season with Miami, Warfield caught only 28 passes but recorded 703 yards, an average of 25.1 yards per catch. He was invited to his first Pro Bowl with the Dolphins and was named a second-team All-Pro by the NEA. In 1971, Warfield caught 43 passes for 996 yards and again led the league in receiving touchdowns, with 11. He earned first-team All-Pro honors from the AP and UPI, among other selectors, and made his fourth consecutive Pro Bowl appearance. The play, a down-and-in pattern, was tried and resulted in an incomplete pass. Covered by star defensive back
Mel Renfro, Warfield was limited to four receptions for 39 yards as the Dolphins were defeated 24–3. Warfield missed two games in the Dolphins' undefeated
1972 season due to an injured foot but still led the team with 606 receiving yards. Through Miami's three postseason games of 1972, Warfield caught seven passes for 149 yards and carried the ball twice for 41 yards. Although Warfield caught only 29 passes during the 1973 season, 11 of those receptions were touchdowns, with 4 coming in the first half of the regular season finale over the
Detroit Lions. In the Dolphins' three playoff games that year, Warfield caught seven passes for 155 yards and a touchdown. The Dolphins reached the Super Bowl for the third consecutive year, and won it for the second straight time by defeating the
Minnesota Vikings in
Super Bowl VIII. In 1974, Warfield caught 27 passes for 536 yards and 2 touchdowns, and was invited to the last of 2 consecutive Pro Bowls. The Dolphins again reached the playoffs, this time losing to the Raiders in the divisional round. Through 5 seasons with the Dolphins, Warfield compiled 156 receptions for 3,355 yards and 33 touchdowns. In 11 playoff games, he caught 34 passes for 717 yards and 4 touchdowns. Prior to the start of the 1974 season, Warfield and teammates
Larry Csonka and
Jim Kiick made what were then surprising decisions. They left the Dolphins at the conclusion of the season for what appeared to be more lucrative pastures with the Northmen of
World Football League (WFL). The Northmen then moved to
Memphis, Tennessee, without playing a game in Toronto, and became the
Memphis Southmen. Warfield played the 1975 season with the Memphis Southmen, catching 25 passes for 422 yards and three touchdowns.
Return to Browns and retirement After the dissolution of the WFL following the 1975 season, Warfield told reporters he would be interested in rejoining the Browns if the Southmen were not admitted into the NFL. The Southmen were refused admittance, and Warfield was ultimately persuaded to rejoin by Browns owner
Art Modell, who felt Warfield would be a valuable asset as both a receiver and in public relations. Warfield played his final two pro football seasons in Cleveland, catching 38 passes for 613 yards and six touchdowns in 1976 and 18 passes for 251 yards and two touchdowns in 1977. In his eight years with the Browns, he caught 271 passes for 5,210 yards and 52 touchdowns. His 85 career receiving touchdowns were tied for #3 in NFL history at the time of his retirement, and is
tied for 19th most in 2025, and his 20.1 average yards per reception is tied for the fourth highest among players with at least 200 career receptions and the highest among players with at least 300 receptions. At the time of his retirement, his 1,121 postseason receiving yards were the second highest total in NFL history, trailing only
Fred Biletnikoff by 46 yards. ==Career statistics==