Arizona vs. New York
Game 1 Bank One Ballpark in
Phoenix, Arizona {{Linescore| The
Arizona Diamondbacks won the National League Western Division in the franchise's second year. They were managed by
Buck Showalter and finished the season with 100 wins. The
New York Mets clinched the Wild Card in a one-game winner-take-all playoff against the Cincinnati Reds and qualified for the playoffs for the first time since losing the
1988 National League Championship Series against the
Los Angeles Dodgers.
Masato Yoshii faced
Randy Johnson in Game 1.
Edgardo Alfonzo got the scoring started for the Mets in the top of the first with a one-out home run. Then a two-run home run by
John Olerud after a walk made it 3–0 Mets in the third.
Jay Bell's sacrifice fly after a one-out triple made it 3–1 in the bottom of the third, but
Rey Ordóñez's sacrifice bunt with runners on first and third made it 4–1 Mets in the fourth.
Erubiel Durazo's home run made it 4–2 in the bottom of the fourth. Then a two-run home run by
Luis Gonzalez tied the game at four and ended Yoshii's night. The game remained tied into the ninth inning. A controversial move by manager Showalter allowed Johnson to stay in the game. Two singles and a walk loaded the bases and knocked Johnson out of the game. He was relieved by
Bobby Chouinard. After the second out, Alfonzo hit a grand slam to put the Mets out in front 8–4.
Armando Benítez shut the D'Backs down 1–2–3 in the bottom half to finish the game.
Game 2 Bank One Ballpark in
Phoenix, Arizona {{Linescore|
Kenny Rogers took on postseason veteran
Todd Stottlemyre, who was hoping to even the series before moving to New York. Both pitchers were on even terms into the third inning. The Mets got on the board thanks to an RBI groundout by
John Olerud in the third after
Rickey Henderson hit a leadoff single, stole second and moved to third on a groundout. However, that was all the Mets got against Stottlemyre, who pitched masterful innings. The Diamondbacks loaded the bases against Rogers in the bottom of the third after two outs on two singles and a hit-by-pitch. Then,
Greg Colbrunn walked to tie the game at one.
Steve Finley gave the Diamondbacks their first-ever postseason lead with a two-run single to right field. Then Finley had two more RBIs with a double to center in the fifth off
Pat Mahomes. In the seventh, the Diamondbacks loaded the bases on a walk, double and hit-by-pitch off
Octavio Dotel when Finley walked to force in a run, then
Turner Ward's RBI groundout off
John Franco made it 7–1 Diamondbacks. The score would stand as the D'Backs evened the series at a game apiece.
Game 3 Shea Stadium in
Queens, New York {{Linescore| In Game 3,
Omar Daal faced
Rick Reed. The Diamondbacks blew opportunities in the first two innings and that would cost them as the Mets would take a 1–0 lead on
Rey Ordóñez's RBI single that scored
Benny Agbayani. In the third,
Edgardo Alfonzo doubled with one out and scored on
John Olerud's single. A single moved him to third before he scored on
Robin Ventura's groundout aided by an error by
Andy Fox to give the Mets a 3–0 edge. The Diamondbacks made it a one-run game when
Kelly Stinnett doubled and pinch hitter
Turner Ward, batting for Daal, hit a two-run homer in the fifth. The Mets blew the game open in the sixth against the Diamondback bullpen. Darren Holmes walked two and
Rickey Henderson's one-out RBI single made it 4–2 Mets. After an intentional walk,
Dan Plesac relieved
Darren Holmes and allowed a two-run single to Orelud and RBI single to
Roger Cedeño. After Cedeno stole second and Ventura grounded out,
Darryl Hamilton's two-run single scored both Olerud and Cedeno made it 9–2 Mets.
Turk Wendell,
John Franco, and
Orel Hershiser held the Diamondbacks scoreless over the last three innings and the Mets were one win away from the NLCS.
Game 4 Shea Stadium in
Queens, New York {{Linescore| In the potential clinching Game 4,
Brian Anderson faced
Al Leiter. The game would remain scoreless until the bottom of the fourth, when
Edgardo Alfonzo's leadoff home run made it 1–0 Mets, but
Greg Colbrunn homered to tie the game in the fifth. Then Agbayani's RBI double with two on made it 2–1 Mets. In the eight, Leiter allowed a two-out walk and subsequent single before
Jay Bell's two-run double off
Armando Benítez gave the Diamondbacks the lead, but the Mets tied the game in the bottom half when Alfonzo drew a leadoff walk off
Gregg Olson, moved to third on an error, and scored on a sacrifice fly by
Roger Cedeño off
Greg Swindell. During the bottom of the 8th inning, Mets 3rd base coach
Cookie Rojas was ejected for arguing a foul ball hit by
Darryl Hamilton, and would be suspended for 5 games for shoving the left field umpire Charlie Williams. As the game moved to extra innings,
John Franco came on in relief in the tenth and shut the Diamondbacks down 1–2–3. The Mets would win the series when
Todd Pratt hit a home run to center field off
Matt Mantei. Steve Finley failed to catch the ball after making a leap to the wall.
Buck Showalter would eventually be fired in
2000 in Arizona as the team underperformed. Like what happened in
1995-
1996 New York with the Yankees, the D'Backs won the World Series the year after he was fired in
2001. Buck managed the Rangers from 2003-2006 and the Orioles from 2010-2018 before he landing with the Mets in 2022.
Composite box 1999 NLDS
(3–1): New York Mets over
Arizona Diamondbacks == References ==