Viewing figures The pilot episode, which aired on September 26, 2007, garnered 14.1 million viewers, ranking number 13 in its time slot of Wednesdays at 9:00 pm
Eastern Time Zone (ET). The first season was shortened due to the
2007–08 Writers Guild of America strike. Overall, it averaged 10.76 million viewers for the nine episodes aired in the U.S., with the pilot being the highest rated episode. Of the regular
prime time programming that aired during the
2007–08 American television season,
Private Practice ranked 36 out of 225 programs, according to the
Nielsen ratings. The series was called "shallow and smirky" by
The Washington Posts Tom Shales, who felt the dialogue and storylines relied too much on sexual humor; he thought the first season would not appeal to ''Grey's Anatomy
fans. David Hinckley of the New York Daily News'' was critical of the pilot's opening sequences, finding they represented the show too much as a sitcom, but felt that it found its footing as the episode progressed and more emphasis was placed on "the more nuanced personal and professional sides of its characters".
David Zurawik of
The Baltimore Sun praised Brenneman and McDonald's performances, but was disappointed in the series premiere. Some critics commented negatively on the characters and the show's representation of women. The series was described as an improvement over the backdoor pilot by
USA Todays Robert Blanco, but he criticized the doctors' characters as childish and seemingly incapable of doing their jobs. Blanco viewed the show as a misstep in Addison's character development, writing that she is "a woman who was once a tough, smart, flawed, sexy adult [who] has turned into a fluttering, indecisive sorority girl". Alessandra Stanley of
The New York Times was critical of the show's interpretation of feminism, describing the characters as "one of the most depressing portrayals of the female condition since
The Bell Jar", and reminiscent of the "seven stages of womanly despair" in
William Hogarth's engraving ''A Surgeon's Progress
. Dough Elfman of the Chicago Sun-Times'' wrote that the actors were better than the show's premise and writing, and
The Boston Globes Matthew Gilbert described the characters as a "stock cast of whiney healers" and the storylines as "hokey, gimmicky medical cases of the week".
Awards and nominations The first season of
Private Practice was nominated for three
NAACP Image Awards—Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Drama Series (Diggs), Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Drama Series (McDonald), and Outstanding Writing in a Drama Series (Rhimes) for the pilot. The series received a nomination for the
People's Choice Award for Favorite New TV Drama. Chad Fischer and Tim Bright won the BMI TV Music Award at the
BMI Film & TV Awards. ==DVD release==