By the first decade of the 20th century, the upscale residences along Fourth and Park Avenues were being replaced with commercial structures. This was because of the Murray Hill Restrictive Agreement, which was enacted in 1847 and restricted the development of non-residential buildings in that area. The restriction extended south of 34th Street, including the future Vanderbilt Hotel site. Later that month, Warren and Wetmore filed plans for a 21-story office and loft building, to be built on the west side of Park Avenue between 33rd and 34th Streets. The building would have had a metal roof high. In December 1908, Vanderbilt filed plans for a 19-story hotel on the site. Existing tenants were asked to leave the site by June 1909. Part of the hotel was to be within the Murray Hill restricted zone. However, the neighborhood's residents did not file any lawsuit against his plans in the year after he filed them. The law firm of
Carter Ledyard & Milburn (who represented financier
J. P. Morgan Jr., a supporter of the restricted zone) told Vanderbilt that it might file an
injunction against him if the hotel plans proceeded, By August 1909, the buildings on the site were being cleared.
The New York Times said the Vanderbilt Hotel, along with the Cameron Building at Madison Avenue and 34th Street, was evidence of the "weakening" of the Murray Hill restricted zone. The
United Hotels Company of America, which was formed in 1910, agreed to operate the Vanderbilt Hotel as one of its first properties. The William L. Crow Company started constructing the hotel in March 1910. The bricklayers' unions went on
strike in September 1910, temporarily halting all work on the hotel. Work was again paused in September 1911, when all laborers went on strike in support of the marble polishers' union, which had gone on strike for several weeks. At the time, the marble was being installed in the hotel. Most laborers returned to work shortly afterward, but the marble laborers continued striking until the end of the year. of which $700,000 was spent on furnishings alone. The Vanderbilt Hotel originally contained New York City's first women-only bar; barely any women used the bar, so it was converted to a men's bar two weeks after the hotel opened. All work at the hotel was completed by March 1913, The
Women's City Club of New York leased Vanderbilt's apartment as a clubhouse early the next year, but it only occupied the apartment until 1918. The Vanderbilt penthouse was occupied in the 1920s by figures such as tenor
Enrico Caruso The Vanderbilt soon became a popular meeting place for companies in the textile and women's apparel industries. In its early years, the hotel hosted events such as luncheons, meetings for the private Paul Jones Club, and a party for
Warren G. Harding's
1920 presidential campaign. The hotel's guests included businessman
Diamond Jim Brady, actor
Rudolph Valentino, philosopher
Henri Bergson, ballroom dancer
Irene Castle, and actresses
Maude Adams,
Dorothy Gish, and
Lillian Gish. The hotel received 47,000 phone calls in the three hours following the stunt. A syndicate led by
Edmund L. Baylies,
William A. Chanler, the general manager Walton H. Marshall, and the hotel's architect Charles D. Wetmore bought the hotel in October 1925. The hotel continued to host events and meetings by groups like the
New York Newspaper Woman's Club, the
National Council of Women of the United States, and the
United States Lawn Tennis Association. ''
Harper's Bazaar'' magazine described the hotel's Della Robbia Restaurant in 1929 as having "never lost its popularity".
1930s to 1960s The Park Avenue Club opened a clubhouse within the top three stories of the hotel in 1933. In March 1935, the
New York Life Insurance Company moved to foreclose on the hotel's second mortgage loan of $200,000. Marshall, who had directed the hotel from its opening, remained in his position as its general manager. New York Life acquired the hotel that May at a foreclosure auction in which it bid $2.419 million. By November 1935, the
Knott Management Corporation had taken over the Vanderbilt's operation for New York Life. Knott then appointed Oscar Banse as the hotel's new general manager. During the late 1930s, the hotel hosted exhibitions such as the Pottery and Glassware Show. A guide in 1939 described the Vanderbilt as "one of the hotels in New York that has kept its popularity for many years".
Manger Hotels bought the Vanderbilt Hotel from New York Life in February 1941, though the hotel's management was retained. The next year, the Vanderbilt's general manager Thomas J. Kelly II announced that air-conditioning would be installed in 100 of the suites. During the 1950s and 1960s, the hotel hosted events like an exhibit of furniture, a showcase of a rare Bible, and a stamp-issuance ceremony. The hotel was known as the Manger Vanderbilt by the mid-1950s. The Della Robbia Restaurant continued to operate within the Manger Vanderbilt, and the hotel also had other eateries such as the Purple Tree. The architectural firm of Finn and Jenter filed plans in 1956 for the installation of a central air conditioning system at the hotel, which was to cost $500,000. By the 1960s, patronage at the Vanderbilt had dropped significantly from its heyday, and there was also rising demand for office space in Manhattan. The
New York Daily News announced in December 1965 that the Vanderbilt Hotel would close to make way for an office building.
Office and apartment use Conversion and early tenants A group led by John Marqusee bought the Vanderbilt from Manger Hotels in April 1966 for $3.625 million. Setrick Construction Corporation was hired as the main contractor. M. H. Lanston leased one of the storefronts, using a portion of the Della Robbia Room as a storeroom, while Lerner Parking leased another portion of the restaurant space as a parking garage. a branch office of stock brokerage
EF Hutton, and
United Cerebral Palsy.
1980s to present By the 1980s, Louis Feil of
The Feil Organization owned the building. After the demolition of the
Art Deco-style Marine Grill at nearby
Herald Square in 1991, preservation group Friends of Terra Cotta started advocating for the remaining section of the room, the onetime Crypt, to be designated as an interior city landmark. The group started a petition and collected 500 signatures in support of this designation. By 1999, the Crypt was occupied by a restaurant called J. T.'s American-Italian Grill, operated by National Integrated Food Services. In 2002, Israel Berger & Associates restored the terracotta on the facade for $700,000. Afterward, architectural historian Mosette Broderick said the ground-floor alteration was old enough to be designated as a landmark, but Broderick did not believe that the modified facade still carried historical significance. Two years later, Wolfgang's Steakhouse opened within the space. During the 2010s, 4 Park Avenue contained the offices of property manager Charles H. Greenthal & Co., as well as a
Crunch gym. The building underwent a capital renovation in the late 2010s and early 2020s. In 2021, the
State University of New York's
Empire State College leased the mezzanine and second floor; the Feil Organization still owned 4 Park Avenue. During that decade, the building's other commercial tenants included the Foundry Learning Center, ground-level stores for
Duane Reade and Wolfgang's Steakhouse, and two companies within the basements. ==Impact==