Many stores established in the 1850s and 1860s were located along Broadway south of
14th Street. By the 1870s, stores were being established between 14th and
23rd Streets in the
Ladies' Mile area. One of the first new store buildings in the area was the
B. Altman and Company Building, which opened in 1906. Other department stores such as
Lord & Taylor, as well as specialty stores such as
Tiffany & Co. and the
Gorham Manufacturing Company, relocated during the 1900s and 1910s.
Early and mid-20th century In February 1914, Robert Walton Goelet announced that he would develop an eight- to ten-story loft building at Fifth Avenue and 37th Street, giving the site's existing tenants 60 days to leave. Shortly afterward, Goelet hired Warren & Wetmore to design the structure, Stewart & Company, an existing tenant on the site, leased the southern storefront, as well as several floors of offices. Construction started on July 8, 1914; The Mark Cross store in the building opened on October 19, 1914, relocating from 210 Fifth Avenue. Records show that the building was completed on December 28, 1914, for about $250,000. Initially, Mark Cross Co. leased the building from Goelet, and it subleased the upper stories to other tenants. The upper stories were leased to various companies in the 1920s, including milliners Gage Brothers & Co., watchmaker
Wittnauer, Stewart & Company merged with
Arnold Constable & Company in 1925 but continued to operate a store there. Women's clothing store Emily Shops Inc. leased the basement, southern storefront, and second floor in January 1929, and Stewart and Company relocated out of the building in April 1929. Emily Shops expanded to the third floor that July, and 404 Fifth Avenue was known as the Mark Cross Building by the end of that year. The Mark Cross Co. store in the building closed in April 1936, when the company relocated further north. Emily Shops then leased the northern ground-level storefront and renovated the ground-story space. Emily Shops installed a green-and-white marble wall, with three large display windows on the ground story, and it rearranged some of its departments; the store reopened in September 1936. Goelet continued to own the building until his death in 1941, upon which he bequeathed the building to his family. The Rhode Island Corporation, operated by the Goelet family, then took over the building. According to the
New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission (LPC), the building's tenants included merchants who sold products such as watches, clothing, jewelry, and rubber. Tenants came from such varied industries as banking, beauty care, dentistry, fitness, importing, legal, photography, publishing, and real estate.
Late 20th century to present In May 1967, the Rhode Island Corporation sold the building to Lorraine Gallagher Freimann for an estimated $2 million; at the time, the building was subject to a $1,2 million mortgage.
Larry Silverstein and
Bernard H. Mendik bought the building from Freimann later the same year. Records indicate that Robert R. Zeiller acquired the deed to the building in April 1976. The building was transferred yet again to H & H Associates in 1979; that company owned the building for seven years.
Murray Hill Properties acquired three adjacent structures at 396 to 400 Fifth Avenue in 1987, with plans to construct a 31-story The LPC designated 404 Fifth Avenue and the nearby
2 Park Avenue as official city landmarks on April 18, 2006.
Joseph Chetrit bought the building in the early 21st century, relocating his office there. Coworking space operator
WeWork also occupied 404 Fifth Avenue until 2021. By early 2025,
Blackstone Inc. claimed that the Chetrit family had
defaulted on a $65 million loan that had been placed on 404 Fifth Avenue. == See also ==