The song has six distinct
movements. The brief harmonised
a cappella intro is titled "Her Man's Been Gone". The "Crying Town" section is sung by
Roger Daltrey in an atypical low register. Daltrey also sings "We Have a Remedy" in his more usual voice.
John Entwistle plays "Ivor the Engine Driver" in that section. Then comes "Soon Be Home", another harmonised section. Finally, "You Are Forgiven" is sung by
Pete Townshend – his only lead vocal on the album (except, on most versions of the album, a small part of "Heat Wave"). "You Are Forgiven" was originally intended to include
cellos, but this was rejected by The Who's producer and manager
Kit Lambert for budgetary reasons. Instead, the backing vocals at the beginning of the movement repeat the word "cello". This song is the Who's first publicised venture into the
rock opera genre (although the songs "
I'm a Boy" and "Disguises" were the result of Townshend's first delve into rock opera, entitled "Quads"), and a precursor to their later, more ambitious project
Tommy. In addition to the studio recording on the
A Quick One album, a live recording appears on
Live at Leeds. When the song was performed live, instead of "girl", Townshend and Daltrey would make a point to sing "
Girl Guide". A performance filmed for
The Rolling Stones Rock and Roll Circus in 1968 can be seen on that film (released in 1996) and on the 1979 documentary
The Kids Are Alright. It also appears on both films' soundtrack albums. Another version recorded live at the Monterey Pop Festival can be found on the Monterey Pop Festival four-disk set and on another Who film,
Thirty Years of Maximum R&B Live. A mixed studio and live version can be found on The Who's four disk set
Thirty Years of Maximum R&B. Another version of this song is available on the DVD,
At Kilburn 1977 + Live at the Coliseum, with Townshend's long explanation of the song and constant humorous comments by
Keith Moon. However, because of problems with the cameras, part of the performance is lost, and was replaced by stylised footage. The
Live at Leeds version of the song was used in the
soundtrack of the movie
Rushmore (though the
Rock and Roll Circus version, specifically "You Are Forgiven", was used in the film). According to the commentary for the film, the
Circus recording is owned as part of the package of
Rolling Stones songs, and it was prohibitively expensive to include on the soundtrack album (which is, similarly, missing the Stones' song "
I Am Waiting," used in the film). A short tease of the final section, "You Are Forgiven", was used to end a concert at the
Wembley Arena on 16 November 2000. That was the first time any part of the song was played live by The Who since 1970, until it was resumed in its entirety for the 2014
The Who Hits 50! tour. Pete Townshend played the song in its entirety on several dates of his 1993 PSYCHODERELICT solo tour. The song was rehearsed for inclusion in
The Who's 2006/2007 North American Tour, but was not part of any
set list. It is likely that the name of "Ivor the Engine Driver" was influenced by the UK TV series
Ivor the Engine. ==Background==