Uthman produced a standardised version of the Qur'an in 652. He sent a copy to each province, and ordered that all other Quranic materials "whether written in fragmentary manuscripts or whole copies", must be burned. It is said that Ibn Mas’ud was displeased by the finished product; in particular: • That he accused Uthman's scribes of adding three extra
suras (
1,
113 and 114) that had never been part of the original, and of making many other small changes to the text. • That he preached a sermon in Kufa in which he called Uthman's standardised Quran a "deceit". "And whoever deceives like this will bring his deceit on the
Day of Resurrection ... I like it better to read according to the recitation of him whom I love than that of
Zayd ibn Thabit ... If I knew anyone to be more conversant with Allah's Book than I am, I would surely go to him if camels could carry me there." He justified his own version of the recitation by reminding people: "I recited before Allah's Messenger more than seventy
suras of the Qur'an. His Companions know that I have a better understanding of Allah's Book than they do; and if I were to know that someone had a better understanding than I have, I would have gone to him." It was said that nobody could find fault with Abd Allah's version. When Uthman was called to account for his mismanagement as Caliph, one of the grievances against him was that he had destroyed variant readings of the Qur'an. The Qur'an says in
15:87 "We have given thee seven of the oft-repeated (verses) and the great Qur'an." The seven often-repeated verses refer to
al-Fatihah, the first
sura of the Qur'an, which Abd Allah ibn Mas'ud is alleged to have denied. However, quoting Ibn Jarir al-Tabari, Ibn adh-Dhurays, Ibn al-Munzar and Ibn Mardwiyah,
Al-Suyuti narrated the following: It is narrated from Abd Allah ibn Mas'ud, regarding the word of Allah, "We have given you the seven oft-repeated verses;" he said, "[It is]
Fatihatu al-Kitab." In another narration, Abd Allah ibn Mas'ud was asked why he did not write
al-Fatihah in his
mushaf. He replied, "If I were to write it, I would write it before every
sura."
Abu Bakr al-Anbari explains this saying every
raka’a (in prayers) starts with
al-Fatiha and then another
sura is recited. It is as if Ibn Masud said, "I have dropped it for the sake of brevity and I have trusted its preservation by Muslims (collectively)." There are also narrations from Abd Allah where he explicitly refers to
suras 113 and 114 as surahs, for example: "Excessively recite two surahs. Allah will make you reach higher ranks in the Hereafter because of them. They are
al-Mu'awwidhatayn (i.e. al-Falaq and an-Nas/nos. 113 & 114)..." Four ''
qira'at'' of the Qur'an (Qira'at of Hamzah, 'Aasim, Khalaf, Al-Kisa'i) have chains of transmission (
isnad) going through Abd Allah ibn Mas'ud, and they all include the above three
suras. These are
mutawatir chains and thus Islamic scholars give precedence to them, disregarding much weaker chains that go against it as inauthentic. For these reasons, Islamic scholars rejected the notion of Abd Allah ibn Mas'ud rejecting
suras.
Al-Nawawi says: "The Muslims have all agreed that al-Mu'awwidhatayn and al-Fatihah are part of the Qur'an and whoever denies this becomes a disbeliever and whatever is quoted from Ibn Masud in this regard is not true."
Ibn Hazm also rejected the notion of Ibn Masud denying these
suras, along with the vast majority of Islamic scholars. ==Conflict with Uthman==