Although constituency tests can prove the existence of an AP in a sentence, the meanings of these AP may be
ambiguous. This ambiguity must be considered when considering the
semantic versus
pragmatic meaning. The following examples prove two things: • Adjective phrases that are pre-nominal create ambiguous interpretations. • Head adjectives that move to post-nominal position creates unambiguous interpretations.
Note: This section can be added into the adjectives page, but ambiguity can also apply to adjective phrases. Additionally, comma placements and intonations may have a role in figuring out ambiguity, but English has a written form of communication that is more ambiguous than spoken communication. The following examples show the different interpretive properties of pre- and post-nominal
adjectives which are inside adjective phrases.
Intersective versus non-intersective interpretation of AP This example showed then entire adjective phrase moving, creating the same ambiguity as example 1. Therefore, the placement of the adjective relative to the subject is important for creating unambiguous statements.
Restrictive versus non-restrictive interpretation of AP The adjective
blessed is ambiguous in pre-nominal position because it creates a restrictive and a nonrestrictive interpretation (a), while in post-nominal position it only displays a restrictive interpretation (b). Plus, when the main adjective of the adjective phrase is moved to post-nominal position, only one interpretation is possible. There is cross-linguistic validity, according to the multiple articles referenced in Cinque's article, which studied this adjective placement in Italian as well. Cinque discovered that exactly the same pattern was seen in Italian, because ambiguous interpretations only appeared when the adjective phrase was placed in pre-nominal position. Next, other research articles also confirm that this
word order phenomenon exists in
Mandarin Chinese, creating ambiguous interpretations. For example, an adjective phrase with the head adjective
private in pre-object position, creates two interpretations. On the other hand, an adjective phrase with the head adjective
private placed in post-object position only creates one interpretation. ==Tree diagram representations==