Pastrana enrolled at the
University of Maryland, where he earned three
letters on the
football team in 1965, 1966, and 1968, and two on the
lacrosse team in 1966 and 1967. He played lacrosse as a
defenseman under head coach
John Howard. After the 1966 season, the
United States Intercollegiate Lacrosse Association named him a first-team
All-American. In 1965, he played football on defense as a
linebacker. The following season,
Lou Saban took over as head coach from
Tom Nugent, and held open quarterback try-outs, which included everyone who had played the position in high school. Saban employed a
pro-style offense. After losses to
Penn State and
Syracuse, Pastrana led the underdog Maryland team to a surprising three-game winning streak over
Duke,
West Virginia, and
South Carolina, which improbably placed the Terrapins atop the
Atlantic Coast Conference and into the
bowl game picture. Maryland, however, lost its final four games of the season to finish 4–6 and 3–3 in the ACC. In the penultimate game against
Virginia, Pastrana broke the ACC record with his 13th and 14th touchdown passes of the season.
Florida State routed Maryland in the season finale, 45–21, where Pastrana's passing accounted for all three Terrapin scores in a failed second-half comeback bid. He finished the year with 102 completions on 195 attempts for 1,499 yards and 17 touchdowns. After the season, Saban left to become head coach for the
Denver Broncos and he was replaced by former Maryland
All-American guard
Bob Ward. In April 1967, Pastrana suffered a serious injury when he tore his
medial collateral ligament and cartilage in his knee during a spring football practice. The injury required surgery, and he was lost for the 1967 season. Pastrana returned for his final year of eligibility in 1968, but had "only a mediocre season", although he "kept the team spirits high with his never-say-die attitude." Maryland finished with a 2–8 record. Pastrana recorded 81 completions on 172 attempts for 1,053 yards and six touchdowns. ==Professional career==