VMI and the "I" formation Nugent began his football coaching career at the
interscholastic level in
Virginia. In his first game as a collegiate coach,
William & Mary routed VMI, 54–6. The Indians' head coach,
Rube McCray, said he would never lose to a former high school coach. Before the 1951 season, VMI was said to have "the finest assortment of material since
Bosh Pritchard and
Joe Muha." The Keydets finished 7–3 for a share of the
Southern Conference co-championship. In January 1952, the
Washington State University was reportedly interested in hiring Nugent as its head coach.
Florida State Nugent took over as head coach at
Florida State University in 1953, and brought with him the I formation. In 1954, Florida State finished with an 8–3 record and earned an invitation to the
1955 Sun Bowl, the school's first
postseason game on
New Year's Day. They were defeated by
Texas Western, 47–20. Reynolds said, "He put FSU on the map in the early years." His overall record at Florida State was 34–28–1.
Maryland At the first practice before the 1959 season, Nugent addressed his team, "Hi, I'm Tom Nugent and I hate
West Virginia." That season, he led the Terrapins to the best season of his tenure and finished with a 7–3 record. The Terrapins also defeated seventh-ranked
Syracuse, 22–21. Nugent amassed a 36–34 record during his tenure at Maryland. Under Nugent, in 1962, Maryland integrated its football team after
Darryl Hill caught the eye of Maryland assistant coach Lee Corso, who had been encouraged by Nugent to find a black athlete to play for his team. Hill became not only the first African-American football player at Maryland but the first in the Atlantic Coast Conference and at any college or university in "the old South." ==Later life==