Sokal affair In 1996, Sokal was curious whether the then-non-peer-reviewed
postmodern cultural studies journal
Social Text (published by
Duke University Press) would publish a submission which "flattered the editors' ideological preconceptions". Sokal submitted a grand-sounding but completely nonsensical paper titled "Transgressing the Boundaries: Toward a Transformative
Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity". After holding the article back from earlier issues because of Sokal's refusal to consider revisions, the staff published it in the "Science Wars" issue as a relevant contribution. Soon thereafter, Sokal then revealed that the article was a
hoax in the journal
Lingua Franca, arguing that
leftists and
social science would be better served by intellectual underpinnings based on
reason. The affair was front-page news in
The New York Times on May 18, 1996. Sokal responded to leftist and postmodernist criticism of the deception by asserting that he was himself a leftist, and that his motivation was to "defend the Left from a trendy segment of itself". The affair, together with
Paul R. Gross and
Norman Levitt's 1994 book
Higher Superstition, can be considered to be a part of the so-called
science wars. Sokal followed up in 1997 by co-authoring the book
Impostures Intellectuelles with physicist and philosopher of science
Jean Bricmont (published in English, a year later, as
Fashionable Nonsense). The book accuses some social sciences academics of using scientific and mathematical terms incorrectly and criticizes proponents of the "
strong program" of the
sociology of science for denying the value of truth. The book had contrasted reviews, with some lauding the effort, and some more reserved. In 2008, Sokal reviewed the Sokal affair and its implications in the book
Beyond the Hoax.
Other critiques In 2024, Sokal co-authored an opinion-editorial article in the newspaper
The Boston Globe with evolutionary biologist
Richard Dawkins criticizing the use of the terminology "sex assigned at birth" instead of "sex" by the
American Medical Association, the
American Psychological Association, the
American Academy of Pediatrics, and the
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Sokal and Dawkins argued that
sex is an "objective biological reality" that "is determined at conception and is then
observed at birth", rather than
assigned by a medical professional. Terming this "
social constructionism gone amok", Sokal and Dawkins argued further that "distort[ing] the scientific facts in the service of a social cause" risks undermining trust in medical institutions. Sokal repeated these criticisms in an editorial for the magazine
The Critic discussing the more general
politicization of science, especially biology and medicine. ==References==