Zeitgeist received mixed reviews, indicated by a score of 59/100 on
Metacritic. Some negative criticism of the album stemmed from the absence of half of the original lineup, with
Pitchfork's Rob Mitchum suggesting the name was revived for "cash or attention or both."
Qs Paul Rees commented that "at least half of
Zeitgeist is made up of grinding songs that amount to riffs, pummelling and little else," and that
Zeitgeists emotional range is "limited and wearing", but praised Chamberlin's drumming, stating that he "remains one of the most powerful drummers in rock." In addition,
Modern Drummer proclaimed that the album contains "Chamberlin's greatest drumming ever put to CD."
The A.V. Club gave it a C+ and said that it "ends up sounding like a Corgan career retrospective in B-side form."
musicOMH gave it a score of two-and-a-half stars out of five and said, "Recounting such thoughts, by this point almost an hour has been spent in the company of a record which stares back at you with the appeal of an ex you'd rather not have bumped into."
Hot Press gave it a mixed review and said, "The best you can offer is that it's not a disaster – now do you want to tell Billy or should I?"
Robert Christgau simply gave the record a "Dud" rating ().
Slant Magazine gave it a score of two out of five and called it "the Pumpkins' most aggressively metal album to date. But heaps of guitars, vocal overdubs, and ridiculous effects don't mask a lack of inventiveness or even plain ol' quality songwriting." Canadian magazine
Now also gave it a score of two stars out of five and called it "no-frills rawk that's been dumbed down for mass consumption."
Melodic magazine gave it a score of three stars out of five, calling the album a disappointing return of the band. However, the album garnered higher marks from other sources, including ratings of 4/5 from
Rolling Stone, and
Uncut. Positive reviews have downplayed the personnel changes, pointing out Corgan's dominance over songwriting and music throughout the band's history. The album was praised by April Long of
Uncut for its energy and retention of Smashing Pumpkins' "signature
goth-
metal-
shoegaze sound." Spence D. of
IGN gave the album a score of 6.9 out of 10 and said, "
Zeitgeist isn't a bad album; it's just not a great album. Which means that it's rather indicative of the times. ... Here's to hoping that the next Pumpkins outing gives into the experimental urge and builds upon the intriguing elements displayed on the album's final two songs. Though we aren't beyond hoping that they keep a little of the apocalyptic crunch intact for good measure, as well." John Cruz of Sputnikmusic gave it a score of 3.5 out of 5 and said, "While not enough to stand among the best the Pumpkins have to offer, Zeigeist nonetheless stands fairly well on its own, Smashing Pumpkins or no." This album was #43 on
Rolling Stones list of the Top 50 Albums of 2007.
Legacy The album divided the Pumpkins' fanbase. Corgan would later admit, "I know a lot of our fans are puzzled by
Zeitgeist. I think they wanted this massive, grandiose work, but you don't just roll out of bed after seven years without a functioning band and go back to doing that". ==Artwork==