The book received considerable praise upon its publication as well as in subsequent years for reprints. On the publication of the hardcover first edition in 1990, critic
Richard Schickel called the book "indispensable and marvelously readable" and "one of the best accounts of the making of an individual movie we've ever had". Christopher Lehmann-Haupt of
The New York Times declared it a "meticulous history of a single film production". Anthony Quinn in
The Sunday Times wrote that "[the book] combines a gossipy retrospective with a serious work of criticism, presenting an articulate guide to Hitchcock's idiosyncratic approach to film-making and the collaborative efforts that underpinned it. The author has conducted interviews with all those involved in the making of
Psycho – its casting, scripting, art design, lighting, editing, selling – in the course of it, we inch closer to the bizarre, unpredictable quality of its director". The critic for
Newsweek called the book "wonderful" and observed, "Stephen Rebello makes reading about
Psycho almost as much fun as watching it".
Psycho star
Anthony Perkins called the book a "meticulously researched and irresistible ... Required reading not only for
Psycho-philes, but for anyone interested in the backstage world of movie-creation".
Images Journal reviewer Gary Johnson called it "one of the best books ever written about the making of a movie". Gerald Kaufman of
The Sunday Telegraph found it "joyously entertaining".
Entertainment Weekly, referring to Rebello's revealing how Hitchcock arrived at the sound of the knife stabbing the heroine in the shower, opined "the melon tale alone is worth the price of [the book]". Another top critic wrote that, unlike other books about films and filmmakers, it "reads more like a gripping novel than detached intellectualism". In a January 6, 2010
Newsweek story called "The Mother of All Horror Films", Malcolm Jones called the book "fascinating".
Robert Graysmith, true crime author of the non-fiction book
Zodiac described the book as "groundbreaking ... the most faithful, comprehensive and first book on the filming of Hitchcock’s masterpiece, the bedrock upon which all
Psycho mansions are erected".
Leonard Maltin, in his "Movie Crazy" blog entry of October 29, 2010, called the book a "landmark". In 2012, a writer for
The Hollywood Reporter declared the book "a masterpiece about a masterpiece".
The Guardian critic John Patterson called the book "enthralling" and, on February 1, 2013, in
The Guardian described the book as "revelatory". David Pitt of Booklist wrote: "There are a handful of Hitchcock biographies—Donald Spoto's
The Dark Side of Genius and Patrick McGilligan's
Alfred Hitchcock, among them—but here, though focusing on a single film, Rebello offers a close-up look at the director that is perhaps more revelatory about the man's character and working style than any full-length biography. A wonderful, absolutely essential book". ==Table of contents==