in his farewell appearance as
Sherlock Holmes, the 1929 Broadway production By 1925, Entwistle was living in
Boston as a student of Henry Jewett's Repertory (now called the
Huntington Theatre) and was one of the
Henry Jewett Players, who were gaining national attention. Walter Hampden gave Entwistle an uncredited walk-on part in his
Broadway production of
Hamlet, which starred
Ethel Barrymore. She carried the King's train and brought in the poison-cup. At age 17, Entwistle played the role of Hedvig in a 1925 production of
Henrik Ibsen's
The Wild Duck. After seeing the play,
Bette Davis told her mother, "I want to be exactly like Peg Entwistle." Some years later, Broadway actress and director
Blanche Yurka sent a note to Davis asking if she would like to play Hedvig, and Davis sent word back that ever since she had seen Entwistle in
The Wild Duck, she had known she would someday play Hedvig. Through the years, Davis said Entwistle was her inspiration to take up acting. Entwistle performed in ten Broadway plays as a member of the
Theatre Guild between 1926 and 1932, working with noted actors such as
George M. Cohan,
William Gillette,
Robert Cummings,
Dorothy Gish,
Hugh Sinclair,
Henry Travers and
Laurette Taylor. Her longest-running play was the 1927 hit
Tommy, in which she starred with
Sidney Toler, which ran for 232 performances and became the play for which she was most remembered. The play
The Uninvited Guest, closed after only seven performances in September 1927; however,
The New York Times critic
J. Brooks Atkinson wrote, "Peg Entwistle gave a performance considerably better than the play warranted." She went on tour with the
Theatre Guild between Broadway productions. Changing characters every week, Entwistle garnered some publicity, such as an article in the Sunday edition of
The New York Times in 1927 Aside from a part in the suspense drama
Sherlock Holmes and the Strange Case of Miss Faulkner and her desire to play more challenging roles, Entwistle was often cast as a comedian, most often the attractive, good-hearted
ingénue. In 1929, she told a reporter: I would rather play roles that carry conviction. Maybe it is because they are the easiest and yet the hardest things for me to do. To play any kind of an emotional scene I must work up to a certain pitch. If I reach this in my first word, the rest of the words and lines take care of themselves. But if I fail, I have to build up the balance of the speeches, and in doing this the whole characterisation falls flat. I feel that I am cheating myself. I don't know whether other actresses get this same reaction or not, but it does worry me. which also starred
Laurette Taylor, whose alcoholism led her to two missed evening performances and refunds to ticket-holders. The show was cancelled, and in the aftermath, Entwistle and the other players were given only a week's salary, rather than a percentage of the box office gross, which had been agreed upon before the show opened. ==Hollywood==