Minor leagues (1939–1942) Iba was friends with Hugh Alexander, a
scout who worked for the
Cleveland Indians. After Iba recommended Reynolds, the Indians signed Reynolds as an amateur free agent for a $1,000 signing bonus ($ in current dollar terms). The Indians wanted to convert Reynolds to
catcher due to his athleticism, but Reynolds refused to change positions. Becoming increasingly homesick and not wanting to spend his entire professional career in the minor leagues, Reynolds considered retiring after the 1942 season if he did not get promoted to the majors. In 1942, Reynolds went 18–7 with a 1.56
earned run average (ERA), 11
shutouts, 21
complete games, and 193
strikeouts in 231
innings pitched, but due to his family and football injuries, he did not enlist in the military and was not eligible to be
drafted. Reynolds began the 1943 season as a relief pitcher, making his first start on June 20. Indians
player-manager Lou Boudreau used Reynolds as a reliever in between starts due to his resiliency. Reynolds led the AL in walks with 130 in 1945. During his five years with the Indians he was primarily used as a starting pitcher, although he did display the versatility that would become his hallmark. He pitched in 139 games for the Indians, starting 100 and finishing 27. Early evidence of his versatility is demonstrated by his 41 complete games, 9 shutouts and 8 saves.
New York Yankees (1947–1954) shaking hands with
Harry S. Truman before
Opening Day at
Griffith Stadium in 1947 On October 11, 1946, the Indians traded Reynolds to the New York Yankees for
second baseman Joe Gordon. A possible trade was speculated throughout the 1946 season. The Yankees had a wealth of infield talent, but needed pitching help. The Indians were managed by player-manager
Lou Boudreau, who played shortstop, but they needed help at second base. Cleveland wanted Gordon and offered the Yankees any pitcher on their staff, with the exception of
Bob Feller. Yankee executive
Larry MacPhail discussed the potential trade with Yankees star
Joe DiMaggio. Though MacPhail initially wanted
Red Embree, DiMaggio replied: "Take Reynolds. I'm a fastball hitter, but he can buzz his hard one by me any time he has a mind to." Reynolds promptly became the Yankees' best pitcher, recording the highest winning percentage in the AL in his first season as a Yankee. In 1949, joined by
Vic Raschi and
Eddie Lopat, he was a star of a Yankee team that won the first of five consecutive league championships, a feat that had never been achieved before. On July 12 and September 28, 1951, Reynolds threw
no-hitters. He was the first American League pitcher to throw two no-hitters in a season and only the second player to do so in baseball history, after
Johnny Vander Meer threw consecutive no-hitters in 1938. This is still the major league record for most no-hitters in a single season, a record that he and Vander Meer share with
Virgil Trucks (1952),
Nolan Ryan (1973),
Roy Halladay (2010), and
Max Scherzer (2015). His second no-hitter, on September 28, 1951, was an 8–0 defeat of the
Boston Red Sox which allowed the Yankees to clinch at least a tie of the
American League pennant. The Yankees clinched the pennant in the second half of the September 28 double-header. Reynolds struck out nine hitters. He walked four, but "not one Boston batter seemed close to getting a hit". With two outs in the ninth inning,
Ted Williams hit a pop fly to Yankees catcher
Yogi Berra. Berra dropped the ball and prolonged the at bat against the dangerous Williams. Reynolds remained calm, telling Berra, "Don't worry Yogi, we'll get him again." Reynolds was correct and Williams once again popped up, but Berra caught this one. In the spring of 1953, Stengel made Reynolds predominantly a reliever, although he notched 15 starts and 5 complete games, because of Reynolds' ability to pitch without much rest and to use his blazing fastball late in the Yankees' afternoon games when the shadows crept over the mound. However, Reynolds injured his back in July when the team bus was on the way to the train station after a game in Philadelphia—robbing Reynolds of his control. During the '53 World Series—his final one—Reynolds started the opener at home and struggled because of his back injury, but recovered to appear in two more as a reliever—winning the sixth and final game of the Series. Reynolds led the AL in shutouts in 1951 with seven. In 1952, he had his greatest single season performance. He won twenty games for the only time in his career (against eight losses). He led the American League in earned run average (2.06), strikeouts (160), and shutouts (6). He also saved six games. He also played in the
MLB All-Star Games of 1949, 50, 52, 53, and 54 (no official All-Star selection or game was held in 1945). With the Yankees, Reynolds reached the
World Series in
1947,
1949,
1950,
1951,
1952, and
1953. Reynolds had a 7–2 record with a 2.79 ERA over 77 innings in the
World Series. He made six relief appearances in the World Series, recording a win or save in each of them, including the clinching games of the 1950, 1952 and 1953 series. Reynolds won the
Hickok Belt as the top professional athlete of the year in 1951. He also was voted the Player Of Year in 1951 by the New York chapter of the
Baseball Writers' Association of America, In 1952, he was the MVP runner-up to
Bobby Shantz of the
Philadelphia Athletics. Reynolds suffered a back injury when the Yankees' charter bus crashed into an
overpass in Philadelphia during the 1953 season. He retired after the following season as a result of the injury. ==Nickname==