1-2-3/Clouds The earliest known performances of "America" came from the band
Clouds. In their earlier incarnation as 1-2-3, they had performed a re-written version of the song that included elements similar to those later used by Yes; changes in time signature, classical interludes, newly written segments, etc. A live tape exists of this being performed at the Marquee in April 1967, prior to the release of any known recording by any artist, including Paul Simon, himself. Simon had recorded demos at Levy studios in London in 1965, and tapes of these were passed to the band by a studio engineer (Stu Francis of Radio Luxembourg). In 1966, 1-2-3 also performed "
Sounds of Silence" from this same tape.
Yes The song was rearranged by the
progressive rock band
Yes in 1970, performing it in concert on the first tour after
Steve Howe replaced
Peter Banks. Yes added elements typical to progressive rock, such as changes in time signature and long instrumental segments, while dropping the song's original
repeat and fade ending. At one point bassist
Chris Squire quotes "
America" from
West Side Story in the intro. The Yes studio version clocks in at ten and a half minutes, with live versions on the 1970–1971 tour extended to more than fifteen minutes. The studio recording first appeared in 1972 on the
sampler album The New Age of Atlantic and was later included on the compilation album
Yesterdays in 1975, the box set
In a Word: Yes (1969–) in 2002, and on the 2003 re-issue of their album
Fragile. An edited version of this recording lasting 4 minutes was released as a single and hit No. 46 on the U.S.
Billboard Hot 100. It also reached No. 20 in New Zealand. It also appeared on the
Yesyears boxed set and its condensed version
Yesstory, along with
The Ultimate Yes: 35th Anniversary Collection. The edited version was also included as a bonus track on the 2003 re-issue of
Close to the Edge, while the unedited studio version appears on
Steven Wilson's 2013 remix of the same album. A live version of the song was included on 1996's
Keys to Ascension as well as a performance from the final show of the 1970–1971 tour (which preceded the studio recording) on 2005's
The Word Is Live.
Record World called the single "An ironic choice of material, but an excellent one." Howe considers Yes's version to be "a kind of lost recording" among the band's work, since it has rarely been included on their compilations, and when it is it is usually a shortened version. When he had the chance to meet Simon in person at a disaster-relief concert in 1992, Howe asked him if he liked Yes's version, and Simon said he did. ; Personnel : • Jon Anderson – lead vocals • Steve Howe – guitars, backing vocals • Chris Squire – bass guitar, backing vocals • Rick Wakeman – organ, synthesizer, mellotron • Bill Bruford – drums, percussion
Charts Bert Sommer version Folk singer
Bert Sommer, a member of the group
the Left Banke, covered the song in the late 1960s, and he also performed the song at
Woodstock in 1969.
David Bowie performance David Bowie performed a minimalist version of the song to open
The Concert for New York City in October 2001. Bowie performed seated on the floor, center stage, with a microphone and a
Suzuki Omnichord.
Other versions American singer-songwriter
Josh Groban recorded it on his live album
Live at the Greek (2003), and has performed the song live on multiple occasions, including a Howard Gilman Opera House for
Brooklyn Academy of Music's celebration of Simon's music in 2008, and at the
A Capitol Fourth concert in 2011. "Paul Simon is one of my favorite artists and 'America' has always been a song I've loved," he once remarked.
Lucy Wainwright Roche performs it, together with
The Roches, on her 2010 album
Lucy. The band
America also released a recording of the song on their 2011 album
Back Pages. The Swedish sister duo
First Aid Kit performed the song in honor of Paul Simon at the 2012
Polar Music Prize award ceremony, which earned them a standing ovation from Paul Simon himself. On
Black Friday of 2014, First Aid Kit released a 10" single containing the song as the title track. They performed a live version on the
Marc Riley show for
BBC Radio 6 Music on September 4, 2012.
Renaissance recorded a version of it in 1981, wherein
Annie Haslam sings as the male narrator without any lyrical adjustments. It remained unreleased until appearing on the 1997 compilation
Songs from Renaissance Days.
Sting performed the song on a quarter size acoustic guitar live on stage on the Paul Simon with Sting tour.
U2 has snippeted the song on multiple occasions during their 2015 and 2017 world tours. ==Chart performance==