The degree of subsequent Norman-Saxon conflict (as a matter of conflicting social identities) is a question disputed by historians. The 19th-century view was of intense mutual resentment, reflected in the popular legends of
Robin Hood and the novel
Ivanhoe by
Sir Walter Scott. Some residual ill-feeling is suggested by contemporary historian
Orderic Vitalis, who in
Ecclesiastical Historii (1125) wrote in praise of native English resistance to "William the Bastard" (
William I of England). In addition, a fine called the "
murdrum", originally introduced to
English law by the Danes under
Canute, was revived, imposing on villages a high (46 mark/~£31) fine for the secret killing of a Norman (or an unknown person who was, under the murdrum laws, presumed to be Norman unless proven otherwise). In order to secure Norman loyalty during his conquest, William I rewarded his loyal followers by taking English land and redistributing it to his knights, officials, and the Norman aristocracy. In turn, the English hated him, but the king retaliated ruthlessly with his military force to subdue the rebellions and discontentment. Mike Ashley writes on this subject;
"he [William I] may have conquered them [the English], but he never ruled them". Not all of the Anglo-Saxons immediately accepted him as their legitimate king. As noble families increasingly divided their landholdings between England and Normandy, cross-Channel ties weakened. By the 1170s and 1180s, nobles living in England, regardless of origin, identified themselves as English and set themselves apart from foreign-born royal ministers such as
William de Longchamp,
Philip Mark, and
Engelard de Cigogné, who were seen as aliens. King John and King Henry III's frequent appointment of
Poitevin and
Savoyard nobles became a focal point for the polarisation between English-born and foreign-born. Whatever the level of dispute, over time, the two populations intermarried and merged. This began soon after the conquest. Tenants-in-chief following the conquest who married English women included Geofrey de la Guerche, Walter of Dounai and Robert d'Oilly. Other Norman aristocrats with English wives following the conquest include William Pece, Richard Juvenis and Odo, a Norman knight. Eventually, even this distinction largely disappeared in the course of the
Hundred Years' War (1337–1453), and by the 14th century Normans identified themselves as English, having been fully assimilated into the emerging English population. == Wales ==