Background The first public word of this production came when the producers put out a casting call for thirteen years old actresses. Despite the producer being her brother-in-law, the director her husband, and one of the writers (Fields) her husband's best friend,
Kitty Carlisle auditioned along with other actresses at the Coronet Theater in December 1953, and had to wait two weeks before being told she had the part.
MacDonald Carey, the male lead, was signed in late December 1953, weeks before Carlisle. Rehearsals began February 8, 1954 under Hart's direction; the setting was designed and lit by Frederick Fox, while costumes were by Robert Mackintosh.
Cast Save for one featured role eliminated during a rewrite in Boston, the cast remained the same throughout all three tryout cities and the Broadway premiere. However, as the Broadway run lengthened, replacements began to occur, as shown below.
Tryouts Anniversary Waltz had its first tryout at the
Shubert Theatre in
New Haven, Connecticut on March 3, 1954. Reviewer Cyrus Durgin sounded a doubtful note about what sort of play it was, "something between farce, drama, and animated comic strip". So the production went to Philadelphia next, opening at the Locust Theatre on March 23, 1954, as part of the
Theatre Guild local subscription series. Reviewer Henry T. Murdock pointed out that the character of Bud Walters "wasn't really a very funny fellow at all, and that his antics were humorous only by the most tolerant definition of the term."
Reception Critical opinion was cool to the play.
Brooks Atkinson of
The New York Times was severe in his criticism of the writers, but gave a pass to the staging: "Taking the material as offered, Moss Hart has directed a suitable performance-- swift, taut and noisy". Like Atkinson, Schaeffer commended the directing and setting, but called
Jean Carson and
Andrew Duggan routine and claimed juvenile actor Mary Lee Dearring overacted. they are doing it a favor.
Change of venue The production moved to the
Booth Theatre, one block away from the Broadhurst, on December 6, 1954. Later in the month columnist Danton Walker reported that
Anniversary Waltz had paid off its entire original investment and was up $45,000.
Closing The original Broadway run closed on September 24, 1955, at the Booth Theatre after 615 performances. For the final three performances, the producers replaced some of the actors with their national tour counterparts, both for experience and to give them the cachet of a Broadway credit. ==National tour==