The placement of adzebills within Aves has long been contentious, with historical proposals to ally them with the
Galloanserae, or the
kagu of
New Caledonia (
Rhynochetidae), Its
morphological resemblance to the kagu was considered to possibly be a result of
convergent evolution, although New Zealand's proximity to
New Caledonia (both being part of the same region of
continental crust known as
Zealandia, which had prehistorically been
above sea level) has led some researchers to suggest the two shared a
common ancestor which lived in prehistoric
Gondwana; another Gondwanan bird, the
sunbittern of
South America, is the closest living relative of the kagu. A 2011
genetic study recovered
A. defossor as a
gruiform, a lineage of birds which includes the
cranes,
coots, and
moorhens. At the time, there were no available
DNA sequences for
A. otidiformis, but it was assumed the two species were more closely related to each other than to other birds. In 2019 two studies came forth with more in-depth
phylogenetic methods. The first from Boast
et al. (2019) using data from near-complete
mitochondrial genome sequences found adzebills to be closely related to the family
Sarothruridae, gruiform birds known as flufftails. Another study by Musser and
Cracraft (2019) was published shortly afterwards, using both morphological and molecular data, found support for adzebills to be closely related to trumpeters of the family
Psophiidae instead; these authors took account of Boast
et al. (2019) dataset and found that the Aptornithidae-Sarothruridae
clade needed 18 more steps compared to Aptornithidae-Psophiidae; the latter classification is thus considered more likely (
maximum parsimony). A 2025 paper recovered
Nesotrochis (within the monotypic family Nesotrochidae) to be the
sister taxon of the adzebill family. Below is the result of their phylogenetic analysis, using the
BEAST program to analyze 9,615
base pairs of mitochondrial DNA: }} ==Description==