In 1824, Fath-Ali Shah appointed Asef al-Dowleh as his prime minister. In early 1825, the northern bank of
Lake Gokcha, which the Iranians believed to be a part of their realm, was seized by the Russians under the orders of
Aleksey Petrovich Yermolov, the governor of Georgia. The Russian army soon advanced further, capturing Balagh-lu as well. The Iranians knew that these locations might be used as a staging ground for an attack on
Erivan, therefore the significance of this went far beyond the sites themselves. Although Yermolov conceded that this was Iranian territory, he defended his action by claiming that Iran was clinging to a large portion of
Karabakh. The Russians also constructed a small fort on the frontier with Erivan, which the Qajar crown prince
Abbas Mirza protested against. In Fath-Ali Shah's court, two factions had developed during the course of building policy toward Russia. One faction advocated for peace with Russia, and the other for war. Both were heavily lobbying Fath-Ali Shah and Abbas Mirza. The first question at hand was what to do if Russia did not stop their occupation of Gokcha and Balagh-lu. The state of the Muslim minority under Russian authority and, lastly, whether and to what extent Russia had been weakened as a result of its internal crises, were secondary concerns. Those who advocated for peace were the foreign minister
Mirza Abolhassan Khan Ilchi; the chief scribe
Neshat Esfahani; the head of the royal office
Manuchehr Khan Gorji; and the court translator and envoy
Mirza Saleh Shirazi. In general, the peace party feared the capability of the Russian Empire and wanted armed conflict to be avoided at all costs. They were more accustomed to dealing with people from other cultures and knew more about Russia. Those who advocated for war were several prominent Islamic scholars led by Agha Sayyed Mohammad Esfahani; Asef al-Dowleh; Abbas Mirza's close advisor
Abol-Qasem Qa'em-Maqam II; and some of the exiled
khans of the Caucasus, who had either been driven away by the Treaty of Gulistan or had fled to Iran after the treaty. The main stance of the war party was that the Russians had clearly insulted the Iranians and been aggressive towards them. Agha Sayyed Mohammad, who was on his way to meet Fath-Ali Shah, mentioned Fath-Ali Shah's responsibilities "both as Sovereign of Persia, and as the head of the Mohamedian faith" in a letter to Fath-Ali Shah. Agha Sayyed Mohammad also brought up the Russian annexation of Iranian territory and the treatment of Muslims. Furthermore, the war party's interpretation of Russian events was more optimistic than realistic, arguing that Russia was weak overall, especially in the Caucasus due to Yermolov's recent defeats and the Decembrist revolt. To advise Fath-Ali Shah and formulate a course of action in this matter, the Council of
Soltaniyeh gathered. The peace party at Fath-Ali Shah's court was ultimately outmanoeuvred and the final decision was to launch full-scale warfare against the Russians. Asef al-Dowleh performed ineffectively on the battlefield, and was among the first to evacuate to the city of
Tabriz. When the Russians captured Tabriz without an opposition, he was in charge of the men in the city's fortress. He was as a result placed under detention in his own house, and after being freed, Fath-Ali Shah ordered that he be publicly flogged for his "cowardly behavior". == Later career ==