Pre-draft Davis was unable to run at the
NFL Combine as he still hadn't fully recovered following surgery for a groin injury.
NFL.com analyst
Bucky Brooks,
Pro Football Focus, and ranked Davis as the third best safety in the draft. Kevin Hansen of
Sports Illustrated ranked Davis as the third best safety prospect in the draft (49th overall). He was ranked the fourth best safety by NFL draft analyst Steven Ruiz. NFL analyst
Daniel Jeremiah ranked him the fifth best amongst safeties (86th overall). NFL draft analysts projected Davis to be a second or third round pick.
New York Jets 2020 NFL draft The
New York Jets selected Davis in the third round (68th overall) of the
2020 NFL draft. The Jets previously traded defensive lineman
Leonard Williams to the
New York Giants to obtain the pick. He was the sixth safety drafted in 2020. He was the first of two Cal safeties drafted in 2020, along with
Jaylinn Hawkins who was selected by the
Atlanta Falcons in the fourth round (132nd overall).
2020 season On July 24, 2020, the New York Jets signed Davis to a four–year,
$4.91 million
contract that included an initial
signing bonus of $1.36 million. Davis entered
training camp slated to be the starting nickelback and primary backup safety. On July 25, 2020, the New York Jets traded starting strong safety
Jamal Adams to the
Seattle Seahawks. Following his departure, Defensive coordinator
Gregg Williams held a competition between David and
Bradley McDougald for the starting role. Head coach
Adam Gase named Davis a backup safety, behind
Marcus Maye and Bradley McDougald. On September 13, 2020, Davis made his professional regular season debut and made one solo tackle during a 17–27 loss at the
Buffalo Bills. The following week, Davis earned his first career start as the Jets lost 13–31 to the
San Francisco 49ers in Week 2. He was inactive for two consecutive games (Weeks 3–4) after injuring his groin. Davis became the starting strong safety in Week 8 after Bradley McDougald underwent surgery after injuring his shoulder. On November 22, 2020, Davis had a team-leading 12 combined tackles (eight solo) and recovered a fumble on the goal line after teammate
Marcus Maye caused wide receiver
Keenan Allen to lose possession during a 34–28 loss at the
Los Angeles Chargers. On December 6, 2020, Davis recorded six combined tackles (five solo) before exiting in the third quarter due to an injury as the Jets lost 28–31 to the
Las Vegas Raiders. Om December 12, 2020, the New York Jets placed Davis on
injured reserve for the remainder of the season due to a foot injury. He would remain inactive for the last four games of the regular season (Weeks 14–17). He finished his rookie season with 36 combined tackles (25 solo), one pass deflection, and a fumble recovery while appearing in ten games with five starts.
2021 season On January 14, 2021, the
New York Jets hired
San Francisco 49ers' defensive coordinator
Robert Saleh, replacing Adam Gase after the Jets finished the
2020 NFL season 2-14. Davis missed the start of training camp as he was still recovering from his injury. Defensive coordinator
Jeff Ulbrich named Marcus Maye and
Lamarcus Joyner the starting safeties in his absence. Davis spent the entire pre-season on the
PUP list/Active as he recovered from his foot surgery. On September 1, 2021, the New York Jets placed Davis on injured reserve to begin the regular season. On October 2, 2021, the New York Jets activated Davis from injured reserve after missing the first three games (Weeks 1–3).. During his absence, starting strong safety Lamarcus Joyner injured his elbow and was placed on injured reserve. In Week 5, Davis was appointed as the starting strong safety for the remainder of the season taking the starting role from
Adrian Colbert. In Week 7, Davis collected a season-high 11 combined tackles (ten solo) as the Jets lost 13–54 at the
New England Patriots. On December 19, 2021, Davis made eight combined tackles (three solo) and had his first career interception on a pass thrown by
Tua Tagovailoa to tight end
Mike Gesicki during a 24–31 loss at the
Miami Dolphins. On December 24, 2021, the New York Jets placed Davis on the
COVID-19/Reserve list and he was subsequently inactive for a Week 16 victory against the
Jacksonville Jaguars. He finished the
2021 NFL season with 62 combined tackles (43 solo), three pass deflections, two interceptions, and was credited with half a sack while appearing in 13 games with ten starts. He received an overall grade of 60.7 by Pro Football Focus, which ranked 44th out of 64 safeties and earned a coverage grade of 66.1 which ranked 34th amongst all safeties in 2021.
2022 season The job as the starting strong safety was available after Marcus Maye departed during free agency. Throughout training camp, Davis competed for the role against Lamarcus Joyner,
Jason Pinnock,
Will Parks, and
Tony Adams. Head coach Robert Saleh named Davis as a backup free safety to start the season, behind starter
Jordan Whitehead and starting strong safety Lamarcus Joyner. On September 18, 2022, Davis made one solo tackle, had his only pass break up of the season, and intercepted a pass by
Jacoby Brissett to wide receiver
Amari Cooper in the closing seconds to seal a 31–30 victory at the
Cleveland Browns. He was inactive during a Week 7 victory at the
Denver Broncos after injuring his hamstring. He re-aggravated his hamstring injury and subsequently was sidelined for two more games (Weeks 13–14). He was mainly limited to appearing on special teams in 2022 and only recorded three combined tackles (one solo), one pass deflection, and one interception in 14 games with no starts.
2023 season Lamarcus Joyner departed in free agency and was replaced by
Chuck Clark. The starting free safety role was available after Clark to his ACL and was ruled out for the entire
2023 NFL season. The New York Jets signed free agent
Adrian Amos to compete for the job against Davis and Tony Adams. Defensive coordinator
Jeff Ulbrich chose
Tony Adams and Jordan Whitehead to begin the season as the starting safeties, which pushed Davis into a backup safety. On November 19, 2013, Davis broke up a pass attempt and intercepted a pass by
Josh Allen and returned it for a career-high 51–yards during a 6–32 loss at the
Buffalo Bills. In Week 15, he collected a season-high six combined tackles (four solo) as the Jets were routed 0–30 at the
Miami Dolphins. In Week 18, Davis recorded five combined tackles (three solo), a season-high three pass deflections, and intercepted a pass attempt by
Bailey Zappe during a 17–3 victory at the
New England Patriots. He finished with 37 combined tackles (23 solo), eight pass deflections, three interceptions, and three fumble recoveries in 17 games and five starts.
Pro Football Focus gave Davis an overall grade of 74.7 in 2023.
2024 season On April 14, 2024, the New York Jets signed Davis to a one–year, $2.74 million contract that includes an initial signing bonus of $157,500. Following the departure of Jordan Whitehead via free agency, head coach
Robert Saleh stated their would be an open competition for both starting safety roles between Davis, Chuck Clark, and Tony Adams. He began the regular season as a backup safety, behind starters Chuck Clark and Tony Adams. On October 8, 2024, the New York Jets fired head coach Robert Saleh after a 2–3 start and named defensive coordinator Jeff Ulbrich as the interim head coach. In Week 6, he racked up a season-high nine combined tackles (six solo) during a 20–23 loss at the
Buffalo Bills. The following week, Davis recorded two solo tackles before suffering a head injury early in the fourth quarter and was removed from the Jets' 15–37 loss at the
Pittsburgh Steelers in Week 7. He was diagnosed with a
concussion and remained inactive in concussion protocol for the next two games (Weeks 8–9). On January 5, 2025, Davis earned his first and only start of the season after Chuck Clark tore his pectoral muscle and collected a season-high tying nine combined tackles (eight solo), a season-high two pass break ups, and a career-high two interceptions off passes thrown by
Tyler Huntley during a 20–32 victory against the
Miami Dolphins. He finished the
2024 NFL season with a total of 35 combined tackles (25 solo), two pass deflections, and two interceptions in 15 games and one start.
Miami Dolphins 2025 season On March 13, 2025, Davis signed with the
Miami Dolphins on a one-year, $3 million contract. ==NFL career statistics==