Prior to its collection it had been assumed by Thomson that the species was close to the other "island hens" known in the Atlantic, possibly a
gallinule, The generic name
Atlantisia was named for the mythical island of
Atlantis, destroyed by a volcano. The specific name
rogersi honours the Rev. Rogers, who collected and sent the first specimens of the species to Lowe. In his 1928 paper on the species, Lowe thought the Inaccessible Island rail was the descendant of flightless ancestors which had reached Inaccessible Island via a
land bridge or sunken continent such as
Lemuria. Land bridges were commonly invoked to explain biogeographical distribution patterns before the development and acceptance of
plate tectonics. By 1955 it was understood that the rail was the descendant of ancestors that had flown to Inaccessible Island. It was also presumed that, like most other land birds of the Tristan Archipelago (except the
Tristan moorhen Gallinula nesiotis and the Gough moorhen
G. comeri), it had probably reached the island from ancestors in South America. The most recent comparative morphological study to include the genus, in 1998, placed it in a subtribe Crecina of the crakes. Its exact position could not be determined, but it was suggested to perhaps be the
sister taxon to the genus
Laterallus, a genus of small crakes found mostly in South America. Two extinct flightless species of rail were at one time placed in the genus
Atlantisia with the Inaccessible Island rail. The
Ascension crake (
Mundia elpenor) and the
Saint Helena swamphen (
Aphanocrex podarces) were once considered congeners of
A. rogersi. The Ascension crake disappeared some time before 1700 but was briefly mentioned and described by traveller and hobby naturalist
Peter Mundy in 1656. The Saint Helena swamphen disappeared before 1600 and has never been encountered alive by scientists. In 1973 Olson synonymised the
genus Aphanocrex with the genus
Atlantisia, and described the Ascension crake as being congeneric. Stervander
et al. (2019) resolved the taxonomic affinity and evolutionary history of the Inaccessible Island rail by
phylogenetic analyses of the
DNA sequence of its full
mitochondrial genome and a handful mitochondrial and nuclear genetic markers. According to this study, the Inaccessible Island rail belongs to a clade comprising its sister species, the
dot-winged crake, the
black rail (
Laterallus jamaicensis) in America, and most likely the
Galápagos crake (
Laterallus spilonota), therefore suggested referring the Inaccessible Island rail to the genus
Laterallus. It colonized Inaccessible Island from South America c.
1.5 million years ago. ==Morphology==