The Sargasso shearwater belongs to the genus
Puffinus of mid-sized and small shearwaters. Within
Puffinus, the
taxonomy of this species has been convoluted. It has traditionally been considered the
nominate subspecies of the larger Audubon's shearwater complex, which included up to 10
subspecies. Although of somewhat limited value in procellariiform birds, analysis of
mtDNA cytochrome b sequence data indicated that at least three major
clades were distinguished within the traditional "Audubon's shearwater" complex. Following further genomic research, the majority of these taxa are now generally considered to comprise their own species, including Sargasso shearwater.
The lherminieri clade (Atlantic Ocean, Caribbean) •
Sargasso shearwater,
Puffinus lherminieri Lesson, 1839 – breeds throughout the Caribbean, on the
Bahamas and formerly on
Bermuda; ranges throughout the Caribbean and up the North American Atlantic coast up to southern
Canada, with vagrants having been recorded off north-eastern Canada.
The persicus clade (West Indian Ocean) •
Persian shearwater,
Puffinus persicus Hume, 1837 – breeds on
Khuriya Muriya Islands (
Arabian Sea); ranges throughout the Arabian Sea. This group is the most confusing of all. The subspecies
dichrous occurs in two areas which appear to be separated by the whole of
Indonesia and the seas surrounding it; the Pacific subpopulation includes the proposed subspecies
polynesiae (
Ta'ū,
American Samoa) and possibly
gunax (see below), whereas the geographically separated Indian Ocean subpopulation contains the birds formerly separated as
nicolae (NW Indian Ocean, from Aldabra to the
Maldives) and
colstoni (
Aldabra, Arabian Sea). . There appear to be no significant genetical or morphological differences between these birds, which is quite amazing given that the Pacific and Indian Ocean subpopulations must have been isolated for a fairly long time, and that no less than three unequivocally distinct subspecies (
bailloni,
persicus and
temptator) occur within the range of Indian Ocean
dichrous. On the other hand, the supposed species Mascarene shearwater (
P. atrodorsalis) is inseparable morphologically and genetically from
bailloni. Clearly, some mechanism blocking
gene flow is at work, but what this is exactly remains unknown – though as remarked above, separate breeding seasons seem a reasonable assumption and are tentatively supported by the available field data. been proposed as a distinct species, Bannerman's shearwater (
P. bannermani). In the absence of more recent data to investigate this claim, its status continues to be altogether unresolved, though the case for it being at least a distinct subspecies in the
bailloni clade seems good. The little-known
Heinroth's shearwater (
P. heinrothi) was sometimes considered a subspecies of either the Audubon's or the little shearwater complexes. Its actual relationships remain uncertain due to lack of specimens. ==Footnotes==