A
phylogenetic analysis of
Aurornis published in 2013 found that it belongs in the bird lineage, in a more
basal position than
Archaeopteryx. On the other hand, a phylogenetic analysis conducted by Brusatte
et al. (2014) recovered
Aurornis outside Avialae; it was recovered as a
troodontid closely related to
Anchiornis,
Xiaotingia and
Eosinopteryx. In 2017 re-evaluation of the Harlem
Archaeopteryx specimen,
Aurornis is found to be an anchiornithid. The classification of
A. xui as a bird is somewhat contentious, however, due to the various differing definitions of the word "bird". Recent discoveries "[emphasize] how grey the dividing line is between birds and [non-avian] dinosaurs", says Paul Barrett of the
Natural History Museum in
London. "There's such a gradation in features between them that it's very difficult to tell them apart ... [
Aurornis xui] is certainly an older member of the bird lineage than
Archaeopteryx, and it's fair to call it a very primitive bird. But what you call a bird comes down to what you call a bird, and a lot of definitions depend on
Archaeopteryx." American paleontologist Luis Chiappe said that
A. xui's forelimb is too short for this species to be a true bird. It "is very birdlike, but it is not yet a bird," he concluded. In his 2002 book
Dinosaurs of the Air,
Gregory S. Paul tried to conceptually model a "
pro-avian". In his view, the direct ancestors of birds cannot have been completely arboreal, because in that case they would probably have used membranes to fly. He thought they must have represented an intermediate ecological stage, in which the hindlimbs still had largely cursorial adaptations whereas the arms had been elongated in order to climb. Feathers, originally serving the insulation of an already warm-blooded animal, would by elongation have turned the arms into wings in order to fly. More generally, the proavians would, in view of their basal theropod forebears and bird descendants, have been typified by long necks, a short trunk, long fingers with opposable digits, a decoupling of the
locomotor functions of the forelimbs and hindlimbs, a lack of a
propatagium, a shallow tail, and a weight of about one kilogramme. Paul illustrated his analysis with a skeletal diagram, accompanied by a life illustration of a "
proavis". When
Aurornis was described in 2013, it was at the time the most basal known member of the
Avialae, the group consisting of birds and their closest relatives. The Italian paleontologist
Andrea Cau remarked it bore an uncanny resemblance to Paul's "proavis". == References ==